TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Carol backdrop

Carol

26 February 2016English1h 58m

What critics are saying

Carol receives broadly positive notices from Indian critics, with the overwhelming majority praising the restrained, nuanced performances of Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara as the film's greatest strength.

Read all 14 reviews →
Todd Haynes DirectorPhyllis Nagy ScreenplayCarter Burwell MusicEdward Lachman Cinematography

Not streaming in India

In 1950s New York, a department-store clerk who dreams of a better life falls for an older, married woman.

Critic Consensus

Carol receives broadly positive notices from Indian critics, with the overwhelming majority praising the restrained, nuanced performances of Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara as the film's greatest strength. Critics frequently highlighted director Todd Haynes's delicate touch, commending the film's visual richness, subtle emotional detail, and tasteful handling of a forbidden love story set against 1950s social constraints. The most consistent criticism, raised by a minority of reviewers, is that the film's deliberate understatement and slow-burning pace leave some wanting greater dramatic depth or emotional payoff. One dissenting voice found the film too narrow in appeal, while another felt its exploration of love defying social norms could have gone further.

8 rated reviews · 7 positive · 1 mixed

Praised: Blanchett and Mara's performancesCriticised: slow pace, limited emotional scope

AI-generated summary of 14 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (14)

Updated
Shalini LangerTop Critic· Indian Express
7.0
While Blanchett not surprisingly is great as this very rich and polished yet dangerously brittle woman who starts off as the more confident and even a tad pushy one in the affair, Mara is a revelation as a girl who is as vulnerable as she is generous.
Read full review ↗
Srijana Mitra Das· Times Of India
8.0
Based on Patricia Highsmith's The Price of Salt, Oscar-nominated Carol is a triumph of its lead actors. Cate Blanchett sweeps through the film in a flurry of lipstick and furs. Stylised to her finger-tips, Blanchett makes everything Carol does, down to eating the olive from a Martini, an act of sensual fashion.
Read full review ↗
Aleesha Matharu· CatchNews
8.0
Carol is that rare example of a film that is nearly flawless in design, story and performances. The emotional conflicts are so powerful that it's worth a watch more than once.
Read full review ↗
Johnson Thomas· Mid-Day
7.0
Haynes and his principal actors manage to convey the acute loneliness felt by those in unconventional relationships that society frowns upon. The agony and the ecstasy are all conveyed in fleeting, nuanced moments through exquisitely drawn body language and facial expressiveness.
Read full review ↗
Overall, "Carol" is an unapologetic, slightly mischievous, visually rich, arthouse drama that may have a crossover appeal.
Read full review ↗
Kriti Tulsiani· IBNLive
6.0
Though it's a worthwhile watch in every regard, the brilliant performances alone can be the reason for one to make time for this one!
Read full review ↗
Rohini Nair· Deccan Chronicle
6.0
As a showcase for Cate Blanchett's acting prowess, it is wonderful. As a meditation on a love that defies social norms, it leaves room for so much more.
Read full review ↗
Subhash K Jha· SKJBollywoodNews
5.0
Skip Carolunless you are a fan of Blanchett's smouldering femininity.
Read full review ↗
Uday Bhatia· LiveMint
Not rated
The soul of the film is in the little details—the side glances and nervously tapped cigarettes and jazz records playing in the background—rather than the broader, more easily understood movements of plot and character. If you're watching Carol, watch it closely. Not a lot happens, but an entire world is revealed.
Read full review ↗
Tania Rana· BookMyShow
Not rated
The film is brilliant, melancholic and tender, just like love. Watch Carol to see emotions flow beautifully on the big screen. Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara deliver performances of a lifetime. There's no reason to miss this one.
Read full review ↗
Rachit Gupta· Filmfare
Not rated
Underplay and restraint are the strengths of Carol. This is a film that stays clear of dramatisation. It kills you softly. Even in the end, the much-expected and pending Carol's declaration of love to Therese happens in a blink-and-miss moment. The finesse and skill at work in Carol are spellbinding. This is a film you sit back and admire. Its fragile nature is evocative. Its beautiful women are enchanting. Its look at relationships and behaviour is mature and relevant. This is a film to savour.
Read full review ↗
Udita Jhunjhunwala· Scroll.in
Not rated
A showcase for the towering talents of Blanchett and Mara, Carol is a sumptuous watch. Blanchett's coldness and occasional aloofness are offset against Mara's portrayal of Therese, who is vulnerable at times, displaying controlled devotion at others, and occasionally wide-eyed at her own unfettered self-discovery.
Read full review ↗
Sankhayan Ghosh· The Hindu
Not rated
In one moment it is an American road movie of lovers on the run like Bonnie and Clyde , the next an erotic thriller in motel rooms like Lolita and in another, a lesbian pulp fiction with spies and hidden cameras. It's these hybrid genre elements of Highsmith's text that director Todd Haynes incorporates so well that makes Carol an unexpected love story.
Read full review ↗
Bryan Durham· DNA India
Not rated
While it isn't as 'explosive' a story as the book once claimed to be, you'll find that it is a love story society (at the time) forbade. A love story nonetheless and a rather beautiful, tender one at that. Rather tastefully done, Mr. Haynes!
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Details

Release Date
26 February 2016
Runtime
1h 58m
Language
English
Genres
Drama, Romance

User Ratings & Reviews

Users7.06 ratings

6 ratings · 1 with a written review

Community Reviews (1)

LA
Feb 2016

"Carol" is okay, not more than that. It is quite slow and that's why I think it's a bit boring..

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.