TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Identity Card poster

Identity Card

29 August 2014Hindi1h 28m
out of 10
Unfavorablemost critics didn't like it
Monk Score · 7 scored reviews · 1 not rated

A muddled take on Kashmir undone by weak writing, despite Vipin Sharma's efforts.

Verdict tier Unfavorable, most critics didn't like it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: Vipin Sharma's acting performance
  • Criticised: Weak script and poor direction

Audience

No user ratings yet.

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 8 critics are saying

Critical reception for Identity Card is largely negative, with most reviewers finding the film an unfocused and poorly executed attempt to engage with the Kashmir issue. The most consistent criticism is that the film suffers from a weak script, half-hearted direction, and an inability to balance awareness-raising with coherent storytelling. Vipin Sharma's acting performance is singled out as a rare positive, and one dissenting voice found it a brave and thought-provoking thriller. Several critics noted that the subject matter had potential but was undermined by the director's lack of craft.

How the 7 scores spread

1 not-rated review isn't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 8 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (8)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. SKJBollywoodNews

    Film review ·

    In a film swathed in the aura of a doom there are flashes of tremendous humour and warmth. A brave bold thought provoking sensitive thriller . Strongly recommended.
  2. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    Identity Card would have made greater impact if it were presented as a short film instead of a full-length feature.
  3. Mumbai Mirror

    Film review ·

    A PPT history lesson about Kashmir at the end sums up a conflicted effort that could have been the new Wednesday. Instead, it leaves us to ponder over why the impetus was either on awareness or on storytelling, with both seldom combining to form a sequence.
  4. NowRunning

    Film review ·

    Identity Card does poorly as a film. While the story might connect with Kashmiri's on an emotional level, it would fail to touch a regular audience. Complete lack on efficiency despite having a decent enough story makes Identity Card just about average.
  5. Times Of India

    Film review ·

    ...throughout the film, you keep wondering if it was intended to be a short dramedy or a gut-wrenching tale of suffering. In either case, it fails to make an impact. After all, you can't merely 'touch upon' an issue as sensitive and intricate as Kashmir. We don't know about identity but the film lacks substance for sure.
  6. Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    If anything, Vipin Sharma's acting is what stays with you. Watch the film, if you must, for the intentions and Sharma's skills.
  7. India Today

    Film review ·

    Identity Card, attempts to engage itself with the burning issue of Kashmir, but falls flat. The film is riddled with poor acting, bad script and half-hearted attempt by director Rahat Kazmi....In all, Identity Card is lost in a muddle.
  8. The Hindu

    Film review ·

    Promises a mature debate on a vexed issue but is let down by the callow craft of the director.

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

More Hindi films

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.