TheReviewMonk
Poorna: Courage Has No Limit backdrop
31 March 2017Hindi105 min

Poorna: Courage Has No Limit

6.217 reviews
CriticsMixed

Bayesian avg · 17 critic reviews

7.5+ Exceptional · 6.5 Recommended · 5.0 Mixed

6.33 ratings
Users

User Score · avg of 3 ratings

8.0+ Exceptional · 7.0 Recommended · 5.5 Mixed

Poorna is movie about the journey of a 13 year old Adivasi girl who hails from a village in Telangana and made history by being the youngest girl in the world to climb Mount Everest.

Critic Consensus

Critical reception for Poorna is moderately positive, with most reviewers acknowledging the film's sincere and restrained approach to telling Poorna Malavath's real-life story. Rahul Bose's direction is frequently commended for its simplicity and empathy, and several critics highlight grounded performances as a strength. The most common criticism is that the film's straightforward, uncluttered storytelling occasionally tips into tedium or superficiality, with some reviewers feeling the narrative oversimplifies its characters and rural setting. A handful of critics found the film more suitable as short-form content or felt it compromised depth in favor of broad palatability.

17 reviews · 14 positive · 3 mixed

Praised: Restrained, empathetic direction by BoseCriticised: Overly simplistic storytelling and characters

AI-generated summary of 17 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (17)

Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
7.0
"Fairytales do come true and the story of Poorna Malavath is the proof. Her biopic, directed by Rahul bose, does justice to the extraordinary story of a 13-year-old tribal girl climbing Mt Everest."
Read full review ↗
Neil Soans· Times Of India
8.0
"Returning to a directorial capacity after 16 years, Rahul Bose recognizes the beauty in simplicity and uses it to the film's advantage. Grounded performances combined with stirring music elevate this relatively straightforward tale, making it essential viewing not only for the young Indian woman, but for anyone looking to scale great heights against all odds."
Read full review ↗
Murtaza Ali Khan· APotpourriOfVestiges
8.0
"Barring minor flaws, Poorna has all the makings of a film that's both entertaining and thought-provoking. Now it remains to be seen how well the audience receives it."
Read full review ↗
Mayank Shekhar· Mid-Day
8.0
"Bose made his directorial debut with a reasonably fine, 'Everybody Says I'm Fine' (2001), a seriously upper-class South Bombay English movie with a touch of magic realism. This one could have well been in Telugu. It may be diametrically opposite to his debut. But delivered with much subtly, empathy, and remarkable restraint. Or as they say, on the Internet, delivered #LikeABose!"
Read full review ↗
Subhash K Jha· SKJBollywoodNews
8.0
"Take a bow, Mr Bose. Poorna is not just a tale  of the triumph of the human spirit. We all have a Poorna  inside us waiting to conquer our own  Everest."
Read full review ↗
IANS· Sify
7.0
"The film is a sincere attempt at recreating Poorna Malavath's historic feat and conveying the message of empowering the girl child."
Read full review ↗
IndiaGlitz· India Glitz
7.0
"'Poorna' is a beautiful messaged based film which displays a real life heroic tale of a young girl from the rural parts of India."
Read full review ↗
Vishal Verma· Glamsham
7.0
"POORNA is a story that needs to be told. The movie upholds the power of will, determination and confidence that can make you scale the highest peak, it's a small little motivating gem recommended for those who look for some meaning in their life and cinema."
Read full review ↗
Udita Jhunjhunwala· Firstpost
7.0
"The film handles that with reverence and sensitivity while addressing it's additional motive: to deliver a message about realising dreams, maximising opportunities, encouraging the marginalised to break out of community constraints and caste shackles."
Read full review ↗
Arnab Banerjee· Deccan Chronicle
6.0
"There are no digressions here to blend jaw-dropping footage of the attempt to climb Mt. Everest with a dramatic back story to reach the summit. And thank God for that! Bose tells the perilous story of Poorna without clutter and focuses on human endurance and dilemma. Viewers would instantly empathise with her. The only negative aspect could be the simplistic dialogues that make most characters one-dimensional."
Read full review ↗
Dhrubo Jyoti· Hindustan Times
6.0
"Poorna is well intentioned and but in its hunt for ticket revenues and be palatable for a Hindi-speaking city audience, it sabotages what could have been a great film. Watch it strictly for the newbies."
Read full review ↗
FridayMoviez Reviewer· FridayMoviez
6.0
"As they say 'Beauty lies in simplicity,' Rahul Bose's 'Poorna' is as simple as its characters and much more beautiful. With no big actors(except Rahul), quintessential acting and loads of motivational and inspirational stuff, the film is a must watch. You will surely not be disappointed with this one and will return home with a new perspective towards life."
Read full review ↗
"It is a rare Hindi film that travels to the heart of rural landscape..."
Read full review ↗
Madhuri· FilmiBeat
6.0
"Poorna has its heart in the right place. It's like that comfort food which warms you up on days when things go low. Go for it if you are looking out for some extraordinary stories of ordinary people!"
Read full review ↗
5.0
"At best, Poorna should have been a short film that tells us an inspiring story. Not a must-watch as a feature film."
Read full review ↗
Manisha Lakhe· NowRunning
4.0
"Poorna is the story of Poorna Malavath, who at 13 years became the youngest girl to climb Mount Everest. Although the story is inspiring, the telling of the tale is tedious."
Read full review ↗
Sreehari Nair· Rediff
4.0
"This movie is a perfect example of a city-bred director scanning our heartlands, and instead of taking in all the complexity, all the denseness, stopping to ask himself, "What are the corrections I can highlight in these lives, and how do I stitch together a narrative around these corrections?""
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Cast

Details

Release Date
31 March 2017
Runtime
105 min
Language
Hindi

User Ratings & Reviews

Users6.33 ratings

3 ratings from the community

Community Reviews (2)

Decent best : acting ( lead ) , story weakness : Loopholes in plot , much commercial taste ( at times )

SHSept 2019

It's no problem even if you don't watch this film. But to know the dynamic story, you must watch it. And why you must? Because it's an efficient film. This affectionate-for-entertainment directorial by Rahul Bose is a beautiful, catchy film which gets most of itself very right: the local culture of the underdog tribal girl, the mentor Praveen and the success coming with fully-fledged nationalism without any chest-thumping- all these things make Poorna a memorable film. Watch it in parts, or only the parts- but make time for it. I'm going with 3.5 stars and sure that it is one of the best of the year.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.