TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Welcome to Karachi backdrop

Welcome to Karachi

29 May 2015Hindi2h 12m
out of 10
Unfavorablemost critics didn't like it
Monk Score · 24 scored reviews · 8 not rated

A sloppy, mirthless comedy that even Arshad Warsi can't salvage.

Verdict tier Unfavorable, most critics didn't like it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: Arshad Warsi's comic presence
  • Criticised: weak script and forced humor

Audience

User score 3.8 out of 10 from 6 ratings, Unfavorable
Read 4 audience reviews ↓

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 31 critics are saying

Critical consensus on Welcome to Karachi is largely negative, with most reviewers finding it a lazy, unfunny comedy that wastes its premise. The few relatively positive notices single out Arshad Warsi's comic presence and occasional genuinely funny moments or dialogue as the film's main saving graces. Common criticisms include a weak, logic-free script, forced and grating background sound effects, amateurish VFX, poor pacing, and Jackky Bhagnani's ineffective performance. A minority of reviewers considered it a passable one-time watch for undemanding audiences, but the majority advised skipping it entirely.

How the 24 scores spread

8 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 31 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (32)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Indian Express

    Film review ·

    When the gags are flowing apace, and there some good ones in here, 'Welcome 2 Karachi' keeps ticking. I found myself flagging when the pace dipped, especially in the second half. But overall it is all good-natured and appropriately silly, so 'Welcome 2 Karachi' stays watchable. And it manages to end on a hilarious note, sending us out laughing. For a comedy, that's a win.
  2. Top critic

    Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    In any case, how much can actors do, in what is essentially a live-action cartoon? Director Ashish R Mohan is mostly interested in jokes, and all the best ones are in the film's trailer. I recommend you watch that instead.
  3. Top critic

    IBNLive

    Film review ·

    The film drags on incessantly, a bunch of unimpressive songs stretching out the running time. When the lights come back on in the end, you'll want to run for the exit. It's a big fat bore.
  4. Top critic

    NDTV

    Film review ·

    Only the foolhardy would underestimate Bollywood's ability to do worse, but it is unlikely that you will see another film this unabashedly daft this year. Resist the itch.
  5. Top critic

    Firstpost

    Film review ·

    The film thinks it would be hilarious to use the word 'fafda' as a euphemism for 'f*ck', presumably because Gujjus love fafda more than … never mind. So, taking a leaf out of Welcome to Karachi's script, heed this warning: everyone involved in this fafda film overacts, there isn't remotely a fafda funny line to make you fafda laugh, it looks tacky as fafda, is loud enough to make your fafda eardums fafda explode, and long enough to deplete your fafda hairline. I have a few good friends in Karachi. My deepest apologies to all of them on behalf of Bollywood.
  6. India Glitz

    Film review ·

    ...is a crazy goofy mindless fun having Arshad and Jackky posting similes on the audience face. If you love no brainers. WTC is your ticket.
  7. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    What follows is a half funny, half not so funny adventure of the two bumbling idiots, who are by now desperate to get back to this side of the border. What stands out in this film is the fairly intelligent writing, which includes a few uproariously funny dialogues, and which belies the writer's (Vrijesh Hirjee) fair understanding of the current political scenario.
  8. Deccan Chronicle

    Film review ·

    ...tries to be dark and comic, but it's mostly a ha-ha-he-he satire where the joke is on all things — men and nations — macho and flexed. This description makes the film sound sublime. It's not. It's plain ridiculous and fun. It has the sort of jokes that you know are going to be dragged till our sides split.
  9. FridayMoviez

    Film review ·

    A few scenes in the film are definitely entertaining including the parliament one. The comic timing of the actors takes the cake away at quite a few places too and then Lauren Dance number is worth watching as well. We would not say that the film cannot be missed but it's not absolutely bad either. So if you have nothing that you are looking forward to do this weekend, go watch it at a theatre near you.
  10. Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    It's a mindless film, but with some great fun-filled moments. Going by the logic of Welcome To Karachi, it won't be a good idea to travel inside Pakistan without a gun. But, cinematic liberty suggests us to overlook such things and then Welcome To Karachi becomes a one-time watch.
  11. Sify

    Film review ·

    It's one thing to caricaturize for humour, and another thing to completely misrepresent something. One also wishes the humour wasn't accompanied by the insufferable background core and sound effects. However, if you can look beyond these flaws, the film is worth your time for the unique story, performances and some genuine laughs.
  12. The Navhind Times

    Film review ·

    The story of a dumb and dumber Indian mistakenly landing on the shores of Pakistan is the not the story of your average Bollywood film, the jokes in it though cater to the lowest common denominator. The director Ashish R Mohan, was Rohit Shetty's assistant, hence that should come as no surprise. Welcome to Karachi is okay for a few silly laughs with silly being the operative word.
  13. Bollywood Life

    Film review ·

    If you are ones who found Sajid Khan movies funny or Navjot Singh Siddhu's jokes hilarious, this movie will work for you. The rest who are dreamers like me, that are waiting for that one great comedy that will keep us chuckling even after the show is over, well…that wait just got longer…
  14. NowRunning

    Film review ·

    ...is a slightly better effort than director Ashish R. Mohan's previous film, the stain on humanity that was Khiladi 786, but that isn't saying much. The film neither entertains nor does it inform, and it leaves you asking: what the fafda, man.
  15. SKJBollywoodNews

    Film review ·

    It's not easy to make a non-stupid film with two stupid characters at its helm. Welcome 2 Karachi pulls off that daring feat without falling flat on its face. For that alone this film deserves a bit of our attention.
  16. The Free Press Journal

    Film review ·

    The film has a very cheap look to it. The production values are suspect. The tacky opening credits itself give you the feeling that there's very little of affect to follow. The script lacks basic sense. Even if the characters are supposed to be dumb misfits, there has to be some logic in setting them up on a path to redemption. That's not to be found here. the dialogues sound disconnected. The set-ups are all lacking in finesse.
  17. Yahoo

    Film review ·

    Director Ashish R. Mohan seems to have a flair for action, but could have concentrated on quality humour as well. The dialogues, though witty at times seem like a feeble effort to make the audience laugh. "Welcome 2 Karachi" is a poor desi version of the "Dumb and the Dumber".
  18. Bollywood Hungama

    Film review ·

    The film's plot and direction go haywire right from the word go. With Arshad Warsi being the sole anchor of the film, it was a tough situation for him to carry the film alone. Right from the first frame, the viewers are treated to nonsensical script, forced humor and amateurish VFX. While the film's first half is a complete washout, the only saving grace is the climax. Rest of the movie is just episode after episode of idiotic adventures of Shammi and Kedar. ...can be avoided without a regret.

From our readers

Audience reviews (4)

6 ratings · user score 3.8

  1. famusMay 2015
    7/10

    Two youngsters who wish to go America by Boat will lands accidentally in Karachi,Pakistan. The journey of coming back to India is the story line of this movie. Movie mainly focusing on the comedy.. with well drafted story. One point of time you will think that these two guys are really so dumb and their innocent behaviour will make you laugh. Arshad Warsi's story selection is different and he will entertain us with his style of entertainment. A good movie to watch with family. Rating: Good Movie

  2. Tejas NairMay 2015
    1/10

    I will get straight to the point and save you time by explaining (and hopefully convincing) why you should skip Welcome 2 Karachi for life. The story about two Indian idiots, Kedar (Bhagnani) and Shammi (Warsi) trying to go to America through seaways using a motor boat and, instead landing in Pakistan sounds like an ideal base for a satire. However, the film starts, fools around, and ends with absurdity as its main and the only ingredient. Since it is a satire one does not pay attention to the story. But to depend on extremely unpleasant jokes and cooked-up situations is like depending on the US to withdraw its troops from Afghanistan. The performances are not pleasant either. Bhagnani acts pure dumb, but then he does not put much effort into it as acting dumb comes naturally to him. Although, he does play the comedian if we compare him with the lunar eclipse Warsi, who looks dull after his long hiatus from the screen. Gottlieb cannot act, nor can she deliver her dialogs properly. She should stick to brain-numbing dancing. All said and done, one will enjoy only few chuckles that are caused by random comic situations, which are, for your information, only present in the first half. The second half is worse than Roy (2015) and Kuch Kuch Locha Hai (2015) put together. Plus, I could also sense some exaggeration regarding the depiction of the Pakistani life. Clearly, Pakistan as a country is not as bad as the film showcases it to be. BOTTOM LINE: Welcome 2 Karachi is a satire film which takes it audience on a 2-hour long ride so that it can show how it is NOT a satire film. Skip for life. RATING: 1 star out of 10. Can be watched with a typical Indian family? YES

  3. Jimi DoctorJun 2015
    8/10

    It is sad that all critics unable to comprehend the subject and how was presented. I saw this movie after going through all critic's points to find out the truth. It is sad to note that critics have misguiding views. One has to say how the situation is manipulated at the higher level which was clearly visible and depicted in the story line which fact. The same is put very effectively. This was ignored by our matured critics. We all go to movie theater for fun and not to drag into boring and depressing surroundings. Here all team members have to efforts to give us fun and fact of current situation in Libiya,Iraq, Syria, Pakistan where USA, UK are playing dirty politics for their own vested interest. My request to all see this movie with different prospective rather from the critics point of view. It is worth spending £12 which I did value for money in London.

  4. 5/10

    Welcome 2 Karachi is a comedy film by Ashish R Mohan. Occasional hilarious scenes might leave you in splits, but otherwise, the movie fails in its genre. It turns out be a very average movie. Welcome 2 Karachi does an attempt to add humour to India-Pakistan feud, Taliban Issue, American's interventions, but these all turn out to be merely over-the-top drama. The opening credits itself do not generate any curiosity but are set up in an inferior tone. Kedar Patel (Jackky Bagnani), son of a businessman, gets his US visa rejected for the third time. His good friend and ex-navy professional Shammi (Arshad Warsi) suggests to go to USA by cruise, if not by air. But an accident makes them arrive at Karachi. When they learn that they are in Karachi, both of them in their attempt to come back to India, goof up the whole thing. They are mistaken to be intruders from across the border. Lauren plays the role of Investigation officer who is sure that these two people (Shammi and Kedar) might be a threat to their country. Kedar is dumb and Shammi is loud-mouthed which land them in unforeseen situations. They both definitely generate laughter through some scenes when they accidentally get trapped sometimes amongst Pathans / Mujahideens / Police officers / Talibans etc. Taliban Camp Scene is worth mention, though looks very unreal, but it was so funny. Both Arshad and Jacky are good. We have seen this Arshad earlier also, but as far as Jackky is concerned, he also has shown good comic timings. The movie just projected some plots / sub plots, even attempted to present a satire on so many pertinent issues, but somewhere, the passion got lost in storytelling and the output turned to be very mediocre. Music is below average and an unwanted item number 'Shakira' (by Lauren) was inserted. Welcome 2 Karachi, in spite of hilarious moments and with Arshad and Jacky in the lead, fails to take off !

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

Hindi films like Welcome to Karachi

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.