TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
RC

Robbie Collin

Telegraph

7Reviews
Rarely scored3 of 7 scored
1Publication
The Sheep Detectives

The Sheep Detectives

2026 · Telegraph

The Sheep Detectives is a profoundly odd viewing experience – entirely pleasant, lightly funny and easily absorbed, yet every so often you find yourself thinking hang on a minute, I am watching a flock of sheep investigate a murder, and feel like you are having a stroke. It's a marshmallowy all-age confection, as fluffy as its ovine protagonists, even if some aspects are likely to elicit a species-appropriate meh-eh-eh-eh-eh.

Disclosure Day

Disclosure Day

2026 · Telegraph · Jun 2026

His latest – a conspiracy thriller in which Emily Blunt and Josh O'Connor try to blow the lid off a 70-year-old UFO cover-up – is a rare attempt to pull off those two modes at once, and regrettably ends up bungling both. The result feels oddly empty and, for all its surface-level convolutions, derivative, too: like Men in Black without the jokes.

Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary

2026 · Telegraph · Mar 2026

Gosling is enormous fun in his first solo starring role on this scale, and his character's plight is made all the more tangible because the film itself is so extraordinarily tactile. Excellent practical and optical effects are used in lieu of flashy computer graphics – there must also be plenty of CG in the mix, but you can't tell where – while gorgeous visual textures are everywhere.

Avatar: Fire and Ash

Avatar: Fire and Ash

2025 · Telegraph · Dec 2025

James Cameron's semi-amphibious sci-fi franchise is back, with a new chapter even longer, more humourless and cheesily colour-coordinated than the last. That the franchise has already sunk to repeating itself in its third part does not inspire much confidence in the two still to come. Some of us saw a while ago that turning Avatar into a franchise would prove to be a creative cul-de-sac.

TRON: Ares

TRON: Ares

2025 · Telegraph · Oct 2025

The American film with the most unfortunate title in Britain since Our Souls At Night is a balloonishly pompous science-fiction smashathon... Ares makes an even less persuasive job of this than its predecessor, largely because its one good idea comes buried under two hours of bloated and un-absorbing non-plot, populated by some of the most aggressively charmless characters seen in a blockbuster since the Star Wars prequels.

2.0
TRM 5.4
Full review ↗
28 Years Later

28 Years Later

2025 · Telegraph · Jun 2025

This transfixingly nasty, shrewdly postponed sequel to 2002's 28 Days Later finds a knot of survivors ensconced on the island of Lindisfarne where the otherwise endemic Rage virus has yet to reach. It stands as his finest film since 2008's Slumdog Millionaire.

10.0
TRM 6.8
Full review ↗
Mickey 17

Mickey 17

2025 · Telegraph · Feb 2025

Mickey 17 is a markedly original sci-fi satire that defies easy categorization—a $100m boisterous film that neither belongs to a franchise nor cares to start one. Much like its unlikely hero, in a sea of similarity, it's a sparky one-off that will appeal to anyone longing for the sort of sui generis romp a cinematic 'universe' could never allow itself to get away with.

8.0
TRM 6.1
Full review ↗