TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
All We Imagine as Light backdrop

All We Imagine as Light

21 September 2024Malayalam1h 58m
7.1
from 6 scored reviews · 2 not rated

Weighted from a 7.7 average · Why?

What critics are saying

All We Imagine as Light has received an overwhelmingly positive critical reception, with most reviewers praising Payal Kapadia's direction and Ranabir Das's cinematography as particular strengths.

Read all 8 reviews →

In Mumbai, Nurse Prabha's routine is troubled when she receives an unexpected gift from her estranged husband. Her younger roommate, Anu, tries in vain to find a spot in the city to be intimate with her boyfriend. A trip to a beach town allows them to find a space for their desires to manifest.

Critic Consensus

All We Imagine as Light has received an overwhelmingly positive critical reception, with most reviewers praising Payal Kapadia's direction and Ranabir Das's cinematography as particular strengths. Critics highlighted the film's visual beauty, emotional gentleness, and its compassionate portrayal of working-class women in Mumbai, with several singling out the lead performances — especially Kani Kusruti — as nuanced and affecting. A dissenting minority view noted weaknesses in pacing and emotional depth, suggesting the film does not fully deliver on its artistic ambitions for all viewers.

6 rated reviews · 5 positive · 1 negative

Praised: Cinematography and visual beautyCriticised: Pacing and emotional depth

AI-generated summary of 8 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (8)

Updated
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
7.0
The wonderful Kani Kusruti turns yearning into a full-time job, and just for her, this film which releases in India today, is worth every minute of your time. Beautifully shot by Kapadia's constant cinematographer Ranabir Das, the film is suffused with light, lambent in some places, shard-like in others.
Read full review ↗
Peter Bradshaw· TheGuardian
10.0
There is a freshness and emotional clarity in Payal Kapadia's Cannes competition selection, an enriching humanity and gentleness which coexist with fervent, languorous eroticism and finally something epiphanic in the later scenes and mysterious final moments. This is a glorious film.
Read full review ↗
Ryan Coleman· Slant Magazine
9.0
Payal Kapadia has created an exceptional document of a city and its people.
Read full review ↗
8.0
The beats of "All We Imagine as Light" are calibrated with hypnotic grace creating a rhythm that induces pure pleasure. Each shot by Ranabir Das in this gorgeous and absorbing film has been composed to have the skin-prickling effect of a photograph taken by someone with a deep and attentive care for their subject.
Read full review ↗
Gavia Baker-Whitelaw· EmpireOnline
8.0
Led by two nuanced and engaging performances, it's an impressive achievement from a perceptive independent storyteller. Writer/director Payal Kapadia delivers a memorable and compassionate slice-of-life drama, making a clear statement about the constraints faced by working-class women in India.
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Hungama News Network· Bollywood Hungama
4.0
All We Imagine As Light has its share of lovely moments, but the film struggles with pacing and emotional depth, failing to fully engage despite its artistic ambitions.
Read full review ↗
Bilge Ebiri· Vulture
Not rated
Through her mesmerizing filmmaking, Kapadia creates a world that didn't seem possible — which, of course, reinforces how imaginary this new place might prove to be. The film may end on notes of joy, but what lingers is more sadness.
Read full review ↗
All We Imagine As Light delivers on all of that promise and more: art-house audiences should respond to the opportunity to follow this beautifully-shot, gentle story as it eventually follows its own intriguing mysticism. It's a light for audiences to surrender to, a realist-infused story of three women broadly representing three generations in a city where their hold is fragile.
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Cast

Details

Release Date
21 September 2024
Runtime
1h 58m
Language
Malayalam
Genres
Drama, Romance

User Ratings & Reviews

No ratings or reviews yet — be the first to share your take.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.