TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
The Sabarmati Report backdrop

The Sabarmati Report

14 November 2024Hindi2h 3m

What critics are saying

Critical reception for The Sabarmati Report is largely mixed-to-negative, with reviewers divided on its handling of the Godhra train burning incident.

Read all 10 reviews →

Top Cast

A Hindi reporter struggles with a deadly fact when a train full of Karsewaks is set ablaze in Godhra. Years later, he is asked to help expose the Sabarmati Incident backed by a buried report.

Critic Consensus

Critical reception for The Sabarmati Report is largely mixed-to-negative, with reviewers divided on its handling of the Godhra train burning incident. The most consistent praise across reviews centers on Vikrant Massey's performance, which several critics single out as a highlight regardless of their overall verdict. Common criticisms include weak and haphazard scripting, lack of nuance, and a perceived tension between the film's stated pursuit of truth and its commercial or ideological framing — with some critics calling it propaganda and others noting it is too diplomatic to make a meaningful impact.

10 rated reviews · 5 positive · 1 mixed · 4 negative

Praised: Vikrant Massey's lead performanceCriticised: weak, haphazard script and execution

AI-generated summary of 10 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (10)

Updated
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
3.0
After jumping down the throat of those who speak for balance, the film tries hard at doing a balancing act. How's that for more irony? No nuance, just judgement.
Read full review ↗
Amit Bhatia· ABPLive
7.0
Vikrant Massey has established a reputation for himself, where his presence promises good content and 'The Sabarmati Report' is no different.
Read full review ↗
Overall, The Sabarmati Report is a good watch, and Massey, along with Dogra and Khanna, deserves the credit for taking up this challenge. Vikrant Massey delivers a stellar performance and has pushed his boundaries with this film.
Read full review ↗
Lachmi Deb Roy· Firstpost
7.0
Not just discovering the truth behind The Sabarmati Report, it is always a pleasure to watch the flawless craft of Vikrant Massey on screen.
Read full review ↗
Sakshi Verma· IndiaTvNews
6.0
'The Sabarmati Report' not only pays tribute to the innocent lives lost during the riots but also remains interesting till the end as a film—a medium of entertainment. This film is a must-watch for those who are interested in Indian history and hence, rightly, deserves 3 stars.
Read full review ↗
Abhishek Srivastava· Times Of India
6.0
...holds viewer attention through most of its runtime, but its slightly glossy treatment makes it feel less like a film based on true events and more like a typical commercial drama. While it succeeds in educating audiences about the lasting impact of this tragic incident, the cinematic embellishments somewhat dilute its authenticity.
Read full review ↗
5.0
The Sabarmati Report does, ultimately, seem a little too diplomatic and politically correct. It seems unwilling to go the extra mile in a frank and blunt way, which has good and bad sides. As a factual drama, just alright. As a thriller 'inspired by reality' as claimed in the disclaimers, ditto!
Read full review ↗
Zinia Bandyopadhyay· India Today
4.0
Overall, the film is an honest attempt at looking at the Godhra tragedy and what happened to the Sabarmati Express on the fateful day. However, it gets marred with several issues being put into it - including the entire vernacular vs English journalists angle, which goes grossly overboard, sometimes overshadowing the tragedy. The film anchors on just good performances, but it is not enough to save the severely faulty film.
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Hungama News Network· Bollywood Hungama
3.0
...fails to impress due to its haphazard execution & loose ends in the script. At the box office, it will be flop show.
Read full review ↗
Sukanya Verma· Rediff
2.0
The Sabarmati Report is so flimsy in its execution, taking offence to it would be dignifying its existence. The Sabarmati Report's poorly crafted propaganda masquerading as a crusade for justice is nothing but a blatant embodiment of these very ideals.
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Cast

Details

Release Date
14 November 2024
Runtime
2h 3m
Language
Hindi

User Ratings & Reviews

No ratings or reviews yet — be the first to share your take.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.