TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Winter's Tale backdrop

Winter's Tale

14 February 2014English1h 58m
4.6
from 3 critic reviews

Weighted from a 4.0 average · Why?

Not streaming in India

Winter's Tale is a 2014 American supernatural drama film based on the 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. Set in 1916 and present-day Manhattan, Winter's Tale follows the story of Peter Lake, a thief who falls in love with Beverly Penn, a dying girl who has tuberculosis and occupies one of the houses he breaks into. Lake is saved from the insane Irish gangster Pearly Soames and his henchmen by Athansor, a mysterious white horse who becomes his guardian angel.

Critic Sentiment

3 rated reviews · 1 positive · 2 negative

Critic Reviews (3)

Updated
Renuka Vyavahare· Times Of India
6.0
While the setting, cinematography, background score, outfits, imagery, everything is ideal for a 'magical love story', the adaptation is way too convoluted and unconvincing. It all looks beautiful but you don't feel for the characters or their love, which is a big drawback for a romantic fantasy. Barring Jennifer Connelly's cameo, even performances are mediocre. The two lead actors have no chemistry.
Read full review ↗
Sachin Chatte· The Navhind Times
4.0
You lose interest in the plot right from the beginning; it starts off on a rather dull note and continues in the same vein. All the fantasy and mysticism is even less credible than a fake preacher. The only reason the film is bearable is because it is beautifully shot and the cast is earnest. Pity, the story leaves you stone cold.
Read full review ↗
Siddhi Palande· BookMyShow
2.0
The film punctuates love and miracle yet fails to ascertain that the message reaches across without any hitch. Fantasy-romance meshed with time-travel, gone wrong!
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Details

Release Date
14 February 2014
Runtime
1h 58m
Language
English

User Ratings & Reviews

No ratings or reviews yet — be the first to share your take.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.