TheReviewMonk
Laal Kaptaan backdrop

Laal Kaptaan

18 October 2019Hindi2h 35m
out of 10
Mixedlukewarm or divided
Monk Score · 7 scored reviews · 4 not rated

Saif commits fully, but the sluggish period Western wears out its welcome.

Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: Saif Ali Khan's committed performance
  • Criticised: Sluggish, overlong narrative structure

Audience

User score 5.5 out of 10 from 2 ratings, not enough ratings for a verdict yet
Read 2 audience reviews ↓

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 11 critics are saying

Critical reception for Laal Kaptaan is largely negative to mixed, with most reviewers acknowledging the film's ambitious attempt to craft an Indian period Western with distinctive visual texture, eccentric characters, and a morally complex portrait of old India. Saif Ali Khan's committed performance and the film's unusual thematic ambition — particularly its refusal to romanticize the past — drew isolated praise. However, the dominant criticism across nearly all reviews is a sluggish, overlong narrative that fails to bring its interesting elements together into a cohesive or engaging whole. An over-written script, faltering dialogue, and a loss of momentum in critical scenes are repeatedly cited as the film's undoing.

How the 7 scores spread

4 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 11 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (11)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Indian Express

    Film review ·

    There are flashes when you feel the film will finally say something important, but then it lapses back into stodgy set-pieces which go on and on.
  2. Firstpost

    Film review ·

    Singh, the director, had all the pieces to craft an effectual Indian western: the terrain, the long-suffering sadhu, an age of flux, elements of magic realism, and touches of Shakespearean tragedy. But Laal Kaptaan falters on an over-written script and visually over-told story.
  3. IBNLive

    Film review ·

    Even though Singh keeps away from the sentimentality common to Hindi cinema, Laal Kaptaan lacks pace and certain scenes feel unbearably long. Dialogues, so essential for a historical thriller like this one, falter and flail in critical scenes, puncturing the impact of a unique story. As far as Hindi films go, Laal Kaptaan treads a path less trodden, but it meanders and spectacularly loses steam. It should have cut to the chase, literally and figuratively, but instead, it becomes an unbearably long and pointless pursuit.
  4. Times Of India

    Film review ·

    Somewhere, 'Laal Kaptaan' was perhaps attempting to be a Western movie, with horses, dust, guns and the works, but ultimately, a tedious narrative and a very lengthy runtime pull it down.
  5. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    ensational; but a stretch, sadly...In Laal Kaptaan we effectively experience a valiant attempt at merging the East, with the Western
  6. Film Companion

    Film review ·

    Laal Kaptaan is a boring and self-absorbed period drama – one that is so obsessed with historical detailing, eccentric characters, bare physicality and country-style pace that it forgets to be narratively and humanely absorbing.
  7. Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    Saif Ali Khan's slow-burning period Western beautifully sets up its period and ambition, only to peter off at the most crucial juncture.
  8. LiveMint

    Film review ·

    Laal Kaptaan is the sort of film I wish there were more of – an exploration of the richness and weirdness of old India, one which doesn't try to smooth the edges or create a Disney-esque franchise. Recent films have used our nation's distant past as a reflecting pool of orthodoxy (Padmaavat) and proto-nationalism (Manikarnika). Singh, on the other hand, admits that we've always been a complicated, fractured country, and that entire lives can be defined by nothing more than a desire for revenge.
  9. The Hindu

    Film review ·

    All the interesting disparate elements in the film don't come together well enough to build it into a compelling whole

From our readers

Audience reviews (2)

2 ratings · user score 5.5

  1. 3/10

    This is an unmistakably bland attempt to a period drama which can't even correct it's entertainment. Saif Ali Khan delivers a bizarre performance as a Naga Sadhu and the experiment, however interesting it might have been, didn't work for me. The weakest link though is Zoya Hussain, the interesting 'Mukkabaz' debutant. I didn't expect such a bad act from an otherwise very interesting actress. Deepak Dobriyal is the strongest, the most out-and-out thing from an otherwise bland historical thriller which fails it's characters repeatedly.

  2. Redbil AbsniJan 2020
    8/10

    I think the reviews are deeply unfair. Yes the director fails to keep the twist hidden long enough. (Think, Once Upon a Time in the West) However this is a great slow burn Western. It has the Peckinpah or even J. P. Dutta style of film making. Well worth a watch. Check out the audience reviews on Amazon Prime. I personally think someone has paid to have this movie trashed!

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

More Hindi films

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.