Top critic
Indian Express
Film review ·
It is a little too dark and sparse for little kids, and too obvious for those who have crossed over into adulthood


Weighted from a 7.4 average · Why?
Visually arresting grief portrait, carried by MacDougall.
Verdict tier Recommended, most critics liked it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
Not streaming in India
Critic consensus
Critical reception for A Monster Calls is largely positive, with most reviewers praising its emotional honesty in depicting grief and its visually striking cinematography and animation. Lewis MacDougall's lead performance draws specific commendation from multiple critics, with Rohan Naahar highlighting how the young actor carries the film and overshadows even Liam Neeson. On the downside, some critics find the film tonally uneven in its audience fit, with Shubhra Gupta noting it is too dark for children yet too obvious for adults, and Sumeet Kaur pointing to a narrative inertia that undermines its thematic ambitions.
2 not-rated reviews aren't plotted
The Monk Score is weighted from a plain average of 7.4 · how scores work
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 7 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review ·
It is a little too dark and sparse for little kids, and too obvious for those who have crossed over into adulthood
Film review ·
A Monster Calls is touching and it is lovely and it makes the biggest truth of our lives come alive on screen - "...humans are complicated beasts."
Film review ·
To have captured grief with such raw honesty, not just the confusion, but also the rage, is where Bayona has knocked it out of the park. This immense burden – to project the battered heart of this story, to grapple mortality (and morality) has been placed on the young shoulders of Lewis MacDougall, who, it has to be said, is a rare find. Not only does he carry the film for long stretches by himself, he also overshadows the towering Liam Neeson (who has voiced the monster).
Film review ·
This heart-breaking tale on life and death leaves a lump in your throat. It is enormously engrossing but is not for you if you seek light-hearted entertainment and romantic escapism in movies.
Film review ·
The cinematography by Óscar Faura is visually ensnaring. The special effects live action is enhanced by "paper cutout" animation and allows for great depth. The narration is strong on philosophical and emotional resonance. This is a film that has the power to shake you to your core.
Film review ·
If you love art, this masterpiece is worth your time. The not-so-sublime messages about humanity, grief and letting go not only will move you to tears but it will also clear a lot of things of the complicated creatures called humans. Watch it in order to understand that not all monsters are bad and sometimes they are just there to help you heal.
Film review ·
Despite its best efforts at raising questions about the nature of grief and absolute good and evil, this coming-of-age gothic fantasy suffers from a debilitating inertia that renders it pallid, the stunning visuals notwithstanding.
From our readers
1 rating · user score 7.0
The film is a semi-fantastical drama dotted with splashy visual effects, notably a Liam Neeson-voiced anthropomorphic tree that stalks the young protagonist's dreams and subconscious.Director J.A. Bayona ("The Impossible") again ambitiously examines the mind- set of a boy struggling with adult-size burdens, and he's got perfect material to work from in the insightful script by source novelist Patrick Ness. But MacDougall, fittingly, leaves the biggest mark. In a movie-going season that has trained a spotlight on tamped-down emotion, he's impressively stifled in his own right. "A Monster Calls" is a portrait of coping that's both fascinating and heartbreaking. I go with 3.5/5 for Bayona directed fantasy yet emotional tale.
Credits
English films like A Monster Calls