Saif carries the weight a timid script refuses to shoulder.
Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
No user ratings yet.
Critic consensus
Critical reception for Kartavya is mixed-to-lukewarm, with most scores clustering around the 60/100 mark. Saif Ali Khan's performance draws the most consistent praise across reviews, with several critics noting his screen presence elevates an otherwise weak script. The most common criticism is that the film fails to commit to the weight of its socio-political subject matter, with reviewers repeatedly pointing to safe, over-cautious writing that blunts the film's thematic ambitions. A minority of critics found the film nearly without merit, citing formulaic storytelling and an absence of emotional impact.
3 not-rated reviews aren't plotted
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 11 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review
Despite heavyweights like Saif Ali Khan, Rasika Duggal and Sanjay Mishra in the Netflix film, it comes undone due to lazy, formulaic writing. The cop jeep with the menacing blue-and-red lights flashing on its roof has more character than any human in the film.
Film review
Despite its gripping atmosphere, strong performances and morally complex protagonist, the film leaves behind the feeling of unrealised potential. The foundation for a truly searing socio-political thriller is present throughout but the writing never digs deep enough into its themes to deliver the lasting emotional and ideological impact it promises.
Film review
The film's ideas land, but its soft-edged execution blunts the force of its anger.
Film review
Saif Ali Khan is so flawless that I can't stop admiring him despite the film being fundamentally flawed. Instead, Kartavya ends up becoming two separate films awkwardly stitched together with threads too weak to carry the emotional burden of either story. This could have been two brilliant short films but fails as one feature.
Film review
Can a so-so script be uplifted by a star, through the performance alone? Hell, yeah! Among stars, Saif is probably my favourite Khan. Also, decades down, he still seems relatively underrated.
Film review
Kartavya is taut, gritty and keeps you hooked. The real twists come from the understated characters.
Film review
An earnest and socially relevant crime thriller that's undone by its predictability.
Film review
The film reaches it's destination, but leaves you thinking- and feeling- nothing.
Film review ·
Starring Saif Ali Khan as a small-town cop who grows a conscience, 'Kartavya' is a technically sound and politically expressive film
Film review ·
The Netflix release is a colourless tale of a khaki-clad braveheart, barely different from other films of its type, except for an illustrious cast and slick production values. There's nothing more to say or show in a movie that's utterly predictable and bereft of feeling.
Film review
These days, OTT films flirt with hinterland politics but settle for safe social commentary. The volatile social issues get diluted by a cautious approach. The narrative feels distinctly over-vetted, leaving one with the inescapable impression that a legal team sat directly beside the editor, scrubbing away uncomfortable truths.
Credits
Saif Ali KhanPawan Malik
Rasika DugalVarsha
Sanjay MishraAshok
Saurabh DwivediAnand Shri
Zakir HussainHarihar
Manish ChaudharyKeshav
Durgesh KumarAmar
Saharsh Kumar ShuklaNirmalHindi films like Kartavya
This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.
