TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Mr. Holmes backdrop

Mr. Holmes

24 July 2015English1h 43m
out of 10
Mixedlukewarm or divided
Monk Score · 5 scored reviews · 4 not rated

McKellen shines, but three tangled timelines keep this Holmes from cohering.

Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: Ian McKellen's compelling performance
  • Criticised: Three storylines uneasily meshed

Audience

User score 7.0 out of 10 from 1 rating, not enough ratings for a verdict yet

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 9 critics are saying

Critical reception for Mr. Holmes is largely positive, with reviewers consistently highlighting Ian McKellen's performance as the film's standout element, praised for his convincing portrayal of Holmes across different ages and his ability to convey fragility and depth. The complex, layered narrative juggling three simultaneous storylines also drew appreciation, with Hatcher's screenplay noted for its seamless movement between past and present. Where criticism does emerge, it centers on the three storylines feeling uneasily meshed, with some finding the film affected in its overall construction. The film is broadly seen as a character drama rather than a detective story, with Holmes's emotional reckoning with loneliness and mortality at its core.

How the 5 scores spread

4 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 9 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (9)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    Sometimes, the case isn't the point, but the man in charge of the case is, and as a character drama 'Mr Holmes succeeds as one of the best of the year.
  2. Times Of India

    Film review ·

    At the end of his career, his powers fading, Holmes faces his greatest challenge. Having always dismissed emotions while underlining "Logic is rare", Holmes now needs love to crack his last case. Why? Elementary, really.
  3. Zee News

    Film review ·

    What makes this film brilliant is the complex and layered narrative, which has three stories that unravel simultaneously. Jeffery Hatcher's screenplay shuttles between the past and present seamlessly making the entire viewing a delightful experience. Overall "Mr. Holmes" is a must see for all Sherlock Holmes aficionados.
  4. Deccan Chronicle

    Film review ·

    Mr Holmes attacks your well-nursed beliefs about the detective in other ways as well. McKellen's Sherlock is fallible and fragile and his deterioration is undeniably poignant. This Sherlock has found that even at the height of his powers, his weapon of choice — logic — is no match for human nature.
  5. Indian Express

    Film review ·

    An affected piece of work where the detective is in his 90s, retired, and focused mostly on his prized bees, Mr Holmes involves three very uneasily meshed storylines raised only by the quality of McKellen's striking performance.
  6. BookMyShow

    Film review ·

    Ian McKellen has outdone himself with this performance. His Sherlock has depth and heart. Every actor has delivered brilliantly and the director has portrayed Old England quite believably. Great scripts are rare, and this is definitely one of them.
  7. Firstpost

    Film review ·

    Ian McKellen charms in this slow, elegant look at a detective in retirement. In the fan fiction that is Mr. Holmes, the world's most famous detective, God may be old. But it's not time to say goodbye. Instead say hello to a new Holmes who is now all heart, mind and soul. Older, wiser, warmer, with much amusing ado made about his distinctive hat.
  8. LiveMint

    Film review ·

    While this Sherlock Holmes relies on memory rather than the elementary powers of deduction to recast the case, it also proves to be a journey where he comes to terms with his own loneliness and mortality.
  9. Scroll.in

    Film review ·

    The proceedings are held together by McKellen's compelling performance and his deft switches between a spry 70-something and a precarious 93-year-old who looks back on his fame with amusement and regret. In one sequence, Holmes watches a film adaptation of the story that he is attempting to rewrite and concludes that the dramatisation is overdone.

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

English films like Mr. Holmes

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.