Login to TheReviewMonk

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

Critic Rating

4.4

10 Reviews
10 Ratings
10%
in favor

Audience Rating

6.7
2 Reviews
3 Ratings

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales Reviews

The film ends with hope again, and looking at the current way the things with the franchise are proceeding, Disney needs to bring in plotline and decorate it with a better case of seaworthiness, in order to reach the same level it set in 2003 with Curse of The Black Pearl. A tad better than the last two outings, this instalment lies someplace in middle.

Shalini Langer
Indian Express

3

Let’s just say don’t go in expecting more, and you won’t get less (and even get a surprise or two with Javier Bardem).

Rohan Naahar
Hindustan Times

2

Pirates of the Caribben: Salazar’s Revenge, a film that feels twice as long as it really is, and roughly five times as boring. It’s the sort of film that, when confronted with the challenge to be creative, chooses to have its characters topple over for laughs instead. In the end, it drowns in a typhoon of CGI action, which, as far as death by drowning goes, is perhaps the most painful way for this series to have floated away. But there you have it.

Deccan Chronicle Team
Deccan Chronicle

4

The role, that once earned Johnny Depp an Oscar nomination, sees him take a backseat in the face of conflict; not typical of Sparrow, is it? The nemesis gets taken down by passing characters while he watches on in powerlessness. And the closing shot- which is bit of a healer, if I may add- is so Bollywood in its treatment that you would reach out for your tissue wondering how could someone cough up 200 million, in the hope of turning it into a blockbuster, with a clumsily written swashbuckler like that. 

'Jack Sparrow's rum-swigging, goofball pirate has gone from subversive to stereotype.' 'The bar's slipped so low that even "decent" seems like a significant upgrade from status quo.'

Reviewer Profile
Times Of India

7

Go on this final voyage. The seas might get a bit rough but the pirates won’t rob you off a good time.

This Disney film is a visual spectacle and the credit for this goes to cinematographer Paul Cameron. However, less of Jack Sparrow makes it drab.The film can be watched for nice VFX, but (heartbreak alert!) if you are a Johnny Depp fan I would strictly recommend not watching it.

Bryan Durham
DNA India

5

Really hope this is the end of the franchise, despite it being a stronger outing than On Stranger Tides. Don't want it becoming another Rocky or Rambo swansong. Somewhat entertaining, and yet, still at sea about what's happening. You can go on for the ride, but the franchise won't hold your thrall like it once did.

4

Perhaps it’s about time Sparrow hung up his boots and thought real hard about what his next journey should be, because at this rate he’s just going about in circles.

Bollywood Life
Bollywood Life

5

In my opinion Jack Sparrow shouldn’t have returned as this was an insult to his legend. After watching the film, my reaction was similar to that of Henry Turner, when he sees Sparrow for the first time – disappointed. Watch the film solely for the majestic Javier Bardem and his performance as the undead Captain Salazar. In fact it won’t be wrong to call the ‘lifeless’ Captain Salazar, as the ‘life’ of the film. I give it a generous 2.5 stars, half extra for Bardem and that well executed, resounding climax.

Audience Reviews for Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

  • Pranay Jalvi
    Pranay Jalvi
    39 reviews
    Top Reviewer
    7

    With low expectations, 'Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales' is amusing

    Dead Men Tell No Tales doesn't rewrite the rulebook for the franchise
    or the genre as a whole, and is wholly predictable from start to
    finish, but the likable characters—Thwaites and Scodelario have more
    natural presence and mutual chemistry than Bloom and Knightley—
    creative action set pieces, and Depp finally being put in his place in
    the franchise creates a fun ride that's instantly unforgettable. It
    works well enough as a stand-alone, swashbuckling comedic spectacle,
    thanks to the terrific performances, some ingenious practical effects,
    impressive CGI and a steady diet of PG-13 dialogue. There were couple
    of Scenes which were unnecessary (like where Keira comes out of nowhere
    in the final scene). Otherwise, the movie was overall good but can't
    match the goodness of the First 2 Installments of the franchise

    My Rating : 3.5/5

    May 29, 17
  • Rhiki Ranjan Neupane
    Rhiki Ranjan Neupane
    22 reviews
    Senior Reviewer
    5

    Average.

    Good : visual treat( VFX) , background music , Performances by the cast .

    Weakness : bad screenplay , plot , predictability

    May 29, 17