Top critic
Indian Express
Film review ·
There is so much potential in this Naomi Watts film, but it's incomprehensible...


Weighted from a 3.3 average · Why?
A dull thriller undone by an implausible twist, despite strong visuals and performances.
Verdict tier Unfavorable, most critics didn't like it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
No user ratings yet.
Not streaming in India
Critic consensus
Critical consensus on Shut In is largely negative, with most reviewers finding the film dull, unconvincing, and a waste of its premise. The presence of Naomi Watts and Jacob Tremblay, along with the film's production design and cinematography, were among the few elements drawing any measured praise. The screenplay was widely criticised for failing to build a credible story around its central idea, and the climactic twist was singled out by multiple critics as implausible and poorly developed. One dissenting voice found the overall experience worthwhile, but the majority verdict is that the film fails to deliver on its thriller ambitions.
3 not-rated reviews aren't plotted
The Monk Score is weighted from a plain average of 3.3 · how scores work
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 9 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review ·
There is so much potential in this Naomi Watts film, but it's incomprehensible...
Top critic
Film review ·
I'm not sure which section of audiences the film was made for, but if you get time to see it later on DVD I suggest you give it a spin just to know the reveal, which in my humble opinion gives the ludicrous reveal of 2009's Orphan a run for its money.
Film review ·
You walk into this film, hoping to feel claustrophobic but walk out trying to shake off boredom.
Film review ·
Screenplay writer Christina Hodson obviously did not have a clue as to how to connect the big idea with a credible story. So every attempt at generating thrills and scares appears fake. It's also obvious that the mechanics have been ripped-off from much more assured material . There's no compelling story here and neither is there any involvement. But for the heightened atmospherics, and the presence of Naomi Watt and Jacob Tremblay, this would have been an imminently forgettable experience.
Film review ·
The only success that this film may claim to have is that all ghosts are nothing but the brain playing tricks due to parasomnia.
Film review ·
There's a campy attempt to create unnatural sexual frisson. None of the supporting actors, including the normally dependable Oliver Platt (playing a fellow therapist), brings any complexity to their roles. Watch Shut In at your own peril.
Film review ·
With moderate production values, the film is technically polished with Paul Denham Austerbeery's vivid production designs that are realistically captured by Yves Belanger's efficient cinematography. Nathaniel Mechaly's score desperately tries to elevate the viewing experience. The edits by Baxter and Maryline Monthieux, flawlessly camouflage the fault lines in the narrative. Overall, Shut In is mediocre fare.
Film review ·
A thriller set within closed doors, which would definitely make you not stay at home alone. The whole cast ensemble make the experience worthwhile.
Film review ·
The big twist of the film that comes out of nowhere almost made me burst into laughter. There is no build-up, no effort at developing flesh around the twist to make it believable when it comes.
Credits
Naomi WattsMary Portman
Charlie HeatonSteven Portman
Oliver PlattDr. Wilson
David Cubitt
Jacob TremblayTom Patterson
Crystal BalintGraceEnglish films like Shut In