Top critic
IBNLive
Film review ·
Smart, caustic, funny, this love story will bring you to tears...Take along some tissues and prepare to be manipulated.


Emotionally warm but leans on manipulation more than substance.
Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
Not streaming in India
Critic consensus
Critical reception for The Fault in Our Stars is mixed-to-positive, with most reviewers acknowledging its emotional effectiveness and warmth. Several critics praised the film's humor, restraint, and its ability to make characters linger with audiences, with some noting it avoids the shameless manipulation its subject matter might have invited. However, a recurring criticism is that the film does lean manipulative at times and, for detractors, prioritizes emotional impact over substance. A few critics also pointed to weak directorial vision and an unsuccessful translation of the source material's charm to screen.
1 not-rated review isn't plotted
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 9 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review ·
Smart, caustic, funny, this love story will bring you to tears...Take along some tissues and prepare to be manipulated.
Top critic
Film review ·
You don't need to read the book prior to watching the film, though I did end up reading it after seeing the film, and I suggest you do the same.
Film review ·
This adaptation of John Green's bestselling 2012 young adult novel about a teenage girl in love and living with cancer is far from the shameless emotional pummelling it might have been. It finds its own understated way to earn tears, and that's a tricky thing to pull off given the material.
Film review ·
If you like feel-good, escapist films, this one's not for you. The Fault in Our Stars is one of the most unpretentious tragic love stories told in a heart-warming manner. 'Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened' pretty much sums up the story.
Film review ·
While the film does get manipulative in places and is practically begging you to bubble, mostly it is infused with warmth, humour and acerbic comments. Scriptwriters do a commendable job in keeping the film funny and engaging and ensuring that the pathos don't overpower us. Even then, carry your kerchiefs. But rest assured, you will come out of the theatre smiling.
Film review ·
Overall, the film tugs at your emotional chord making you laugh and cry at the same time. But what makes the film memorable is that the characters linger in your mental orbit much after you leave the auditorium, making it a fine example of a good cinematic experience.
Film review ·
The movie is an attempt at making a teenage relevant story come to life on the screen. In the end, it is an attempt. If you are fan of the book, you might enjoy the film or you might hate it. You can even compile a list of errors or discrepancies between the book and the film. You will enjoy seeing Willem Dafoe but he just doesn't get enough screen time. All in all, either you will cry till your eyes turn bloodshot or you will roll your eyes till you strain them.
Film review ·
Watch The Fault In Our Stars for Shailene Woodley...Based on the young adult novel of the same name by John Green, this tale of first love isn't such a many splendoured thing.
Film review ·
The fault in The Fault in Our Stars is that it is so obsessed with bringing tears to your eyes that it forgets to bring substance to the table.
Film review ·
...lacks the directorial vision that would have translated the sweet, geeky charm of the book. The lines that read smoothly sound clumsy when spoken. The fault doesn't lie in the words. The most un-normal of dialogues and conversations can become magical, but it takes a talented director and a superb cast to make the weird wonderful. Unfortunately, The Fault in Our Stars isn't so lucky.
From our readers
2 ratings · user score 9.0
It taught me how to deal with the most fearful point in life, Death! Once we start any Novel we cannot allow ourselves to stop it in the middle of it. We ought to finish it, but what happens with the characters after the end of the book? It's the same question raised by Hazel Lancaster, diagnosed with terminal thyroid cancer; who thinks that she is a Grenade as she is a cancer patient and it will kill her eventually and that's the reason she is not ready to involve in any kind of relationship. She wants to live a plain and simple life which will be without excitements. Then another cancer survival guy, Augustus Waters comes to change her perception towards life forever, to lover her, to care about her and to never to forget her.
Credits
Shailene WoodleyHazel Grace Lancaster
Ansel ElgortAugustus Waters
Nat WolffIsaac
Laura DernFrannie Lancaster
Sam TrammellMichael Lancaster
Willem DafoePeter van Houten
Lotte VerbeekLidewij Vliegenthart
Ana Dela CruzDr. Maria
David WhalenMr. Waters
Milica GovichMrs. Waters
Emily PeacheyMonica
Emily BachMonica's mom
Mike BirbigliaPatrick
Josh Boone
Wyck Godfrey
Marty Bowen
Scott Neustadter
Michael H. Weber
Mike Mogis
Ben RichardsonEnglish films like The Fault in Our Stars