Top critic
Firstpost
Film review ·
Tim Burton's remake is let down by a complicated screenplay, lack of emotional heft


Visually grand but emotionally hollow, Burton's Dumbo charms the eyes more than the heart.
Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
No user ratings yet.
Not streaming in India
Critic consensus
Critical reception for Dumbo leans mixed to negative, with most reviewers finding the film a disappointment relative to both the 1941 original and Tim Burton's own body of work. The visual scale and the charm of the titular character were the most frequently acknowledged positives. However, critics repeatedly pointed to a lack of emotional resonance, predictability, underdeveloped characters, and a sluggish or complicated screenplay as significant weaknesses. The broad consensus is that the film works better as a surface-level children's entertainer than as a meaningful reimagining.
2 not-rated reviews aren't plotted
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 9 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review ·
Tim Burton's remake is let down by a complicated screenplay, lack of emotional heft
Top critic
Film review ·
In a world full of wondrous things, wonder is the thing in shortest supply. Burton had a chance to make you believe that a pregnant caged elephant, who has spent her life in circuses, could look at soaring birds through a barred window in envy and what may result is an elephant with flapping ears for wings. He squanders it.
Film review ·
Film's visual scale towers above many of its obvious flaws, but doesn't quite lift it above Burton's legacy of creating magical realism in the past. While there are problems such as predictability, caricature characters and a sluggish pace, 'Dumbo' has its moments. Overall, it's a harmless family entertainer for children of all ages.
Film review ·
Overall, while adults will find this film tolerable, the kids are sure to lap it up with full gusto.
Film review ·
Cute and appealing but not Burton's style...Tim Burton's craft is more simplistic here - even though the film is a sort of circus fantasia with all the aspects of an imagination running wild.
Film review ·
This fantasy adventure film, with all the trappings of a typical Disney fare, is the story of a baby elephant, who uses his extra-large ears to fly.
Film review ·
An elephant flies but no one cries in Tim Burton's woke but boring remake of a Disney classic...Tim Burton's remake of 1941 Disney classic fails to take off. It underuses important scenes and introduces needless others.
Film review ·
'Dumbo' gets by on the charm of its titular character...
Film review ·
Tim Burton's magic can't save it...Disney's latest dip into its treasure of archives crashes before it can soar like its main character
Credits
Colin FarrellHolt Farrier
Michael KeatonV. A. Vandevere
Danny DeVitoMax Medici
Eva GreenColette Marchant
Alan ArkinJ. Griffin RemingtonEnglish films like Dumbo