TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Victoria & Abdul backdrop

Victoria & Abdul

13 October 2017English1h 52m
User score: 2.0 out of 10, from 1 rating — not enough ratings for a verdict yet

What critics are saying

Critical reception for Victoria & Abdul in India is mixed to negative, with the majority of reviewers finding the film narratively shallow and historically dubious.

Read all 13 reviews →
Stephen Frears DirectorThomas Newman MusicDanny Cohen Cinematography

Not streaming in India

Victoria and Abdul is a movie about the Queen Victoria, who strikes up an unlikely friendship with the 24-year-old Indian clerk named Abdul Karim, and who's been chosen to present her highness with 'The Mohur' from the Indian Government.

Critic Consensus

Critical reception for Victoria & Abdul in India is mixed to negative, with the majority of reviewers finding the film narratively shallow and historically dubious. Judi Dench's performance is the most consistently cited strength, with several critics suggesting she alone justifies a watch. Common criticisms include Ali Fazal's underdeveloped characterisation, a lack of political or satirical depth, and concerns about the film glossing over or normalising colonial history. A number of reviewers flag factual inaccuracies and a sanitised portrayal of the British Raj as significant shortcomings.

11 rated reviews · 2 positive · 5 mixed · 4 negative

Praised: Judi Dench's commanding performanceCriticised: Shallow, historically inaccurate portrayal

AI-generated summary of 13 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (13)

Updated
Mihir FadnavisTop Critic· Firstpost
4.0
“There's an odd sense of misguided chronicling in the film, which is strange considering it's directed by Stephen Frears who has made rather lovely films like High Fidelity. The lack of irony, or satirical bite from his earlier film The Queen ultimately hurts Victoria and Abdul, more a missed opportunity than a piece of entertainment.”
Read full review ↗
Shalini LangerTop Critic· Indian Express
4.0
“Unfortunately, as told by this film, through Ali Fazal whose Abdul is as two-dimensional as a cardboard, with as little insight into the man transported into an alien world, Victoria and Abdul plays out exactly like a fantasy.”
Read full review ↗
7.0
“Perhaps it's an attempt to make Islam more palatable to a terrorism-plagued West, but it seems tone deaf in a post-2014 India, where it might just fan certain undesirable flames. All in all, we can only end with what the filmmakers begin the movie with, a caveat that "This is based on a true story...... Mostly."”
Read full review ↗
Johnson Thomas· Mid-Day
6.0
“Ali Fazal Fails To Match Up To Judi Dench's Brilliance...”
Read full review ↗
“If you can do away with its racial undertones and its alleged factual inaccuracy, Victoria & Abdul is an endearing tale of love and friendship that will leave a smile on your face for the most part of it. Watch it for its humour and the performances by Judi Dench, Ali Fazal and other actors in the film.”
Read full review ↗
Sukanya Verma· Rediff
5.0
“What it packs with significance is a leading lady whose authority in cinema few can hold candle to. And it's to her credit that even the most dubious figures of history can boast of a heart.”
Read full review ↗
IANS· Sify
5.0
“Victoria & Abdul offers mixed reactions. It is pleasantly sweet but annoyingly off-putting.”
Read full review ↗
Deccan Chronicle Team· Deccan Chronicle
5.0
“Victora & Abdul is a could-have-been-better movie about an interesting story. Despite the ravishing chemistry between lead actors, the film is an underwhelming watch.”
Read full review ↗
FH
Critic· Fully Hyderabad
5.0
“At risk of sounding racist, the movie is one that most people unaccustomed to the Indian way of life will enjoy as to them it is a window into a world (British-ruled India) they seldom make an effort at truly understanding. But to most people inhabiting this country, stories good and bad about the British Raj are ones we have seen and heard before, and with little to no character or grit written for the Indian representative of the cast, the film might prove to be a tough pill to swallow.”
Read full review ↗
Rashid Irani· Hindustan Times
3.0
“Don't be taken in by the delightful sight of Queen Victoria speaking in broken Hindi, and don't fall for a dreamy-eyed Ali Fazal reciting the decadent history of the Taj Mahal. Victoria & Abdul is a shameful attempt to normalise evil. Everyone involved could, and should, have done better.”
Read full review ↗
Umesh Punwani· KoiMoi
3.0
“I wish we could've bid farewell Judi Dench with a more memorable Queen Victoria role. There are a lot of options this week and this one will surely drown in the flood of other movies.”
Read full review ↗
Rucha Sharma· DNA India
Not rated
“The movie is specifically nostalgic about the Victoria and Abdul equation. Don't go looking for political commentary, you will be disappointed with its mild manners.”
Read full review ↗
Renuka Vyavahare· Times Of India
Not rated
“Despite an uneven narrative and historical inaccuracies, Victoria and Abdul is a delightful film that deserves to be watched for Judi Dench.”
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Cast

Details

Release Date
13 October 2017
Runtime
1h 52m
Language
English
Genres
Drama, History

User Ratings & Reviews

Users2.01 rating

1 rating · 0 with a written review

You may also like

English films like Victoria & Abdul

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.