TheReviewMonk
23 February 2018Hindi118 min

Welcome to New York

3.215 reviews
CriticsUnfavorable

Bayesian avg · 15 critic reviews

7.5+ Exceptional · 6.5 Recommended · 5.0 Mixed

Users

No user ratings yet

Chakri Toleti DirectorDheeraj Rattan WriterSajid-Wajid MusicMeet Bros MusicShamir Tandon MusicSantosh Thundiyil CinematographyNeha Parti Cinematography

Welcome to New York is a comedy film, in which Hero (Diljit Dosanjh), a sloppy recovery agent, and Jeenal Patel (Sonakshi Sinha), a fashion designer, become part of a big Bollywood event in New York - and chaos ensues.

Critic Consensus

Welcome to New York was met with near-universal negative reception, with critics largely condemning it as an incoherent, poorly directed promotional vehicle for the IIFA Awards rather than a coherent film. The script, narrative structure, and ineffective 3D effects were repeatedly cited as major failures, with several reviewers questioning the film's basic reason for existing. The only consistent points of praise were isolated performances, particularly Riteish Deshmukh's comic timing and supporting turns by Boman Irani and Lara Dutta, which a handful of critics noted as the film's rare redeeming qualities. Most reviewers explicitly advised audiences to avoid the film entirely.

15 reviews · 1 mixed · 13 negative

Praised: Riteish Deshmukh's comic timingCriticised: IIFA promotional content over storytelling

AI-generated summary of 15 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (15)

Anupama ChopraTop Critic· Film Companion
2.0
"... this incoherent mess of a film plays out more like an extended skit or a school play"
Read full review ↗
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
2.0
"You wish there was more savagery and skewering all round, but Welcome To New York turns out to be a limp, lame tribute to Bollywood. Why would I bother to see this in a film, when TV shows are full of it?"
Read full review ↗
Lasyapriya Sundaram· Times Of India
5.0
"The laughs are few and far between and most scenes and dialogues which manage to tickle the funny bone involve Karan and Riteish. The biggest let-down is the script and the various tracks in the narrative don't always come together as a whole and seem contrived. The visual effects in the film are also tacky, to say the least."
Read full review ↗
R.M. Vijayakar· IndiaWest
3.0
"Lending a thin sliver of respectability to the film are the dignified and smooth turns by Boman Irani as the organizer-in-chief and Lara Dutta as the disgruntled woman. Dutta proves yet again after "Chalo Dilli," "Singh Is Bliing" and "Azhar" that she has taking it easy in her profession just when she has truly evolved as an actor."
Read full review ↗
Prasanna Zore· Rediff
3.0
"The film fails miserably in its intent if the intent were to spoof Bollywood, as it only does that for the sake of punchlines and does not explore it better."
Read full review ↗
Udita Jhunjhunwala· Firstpost
3.0
"The 3D part in the film is a waste. The intent behind Welcome to New York leaves many questions – why is the main one. Why 3D, why make this movie, why give Karan Johar a double role, why not use more cameos? Why watch this indulgent snoozefest? That last question is the only one with a clear answer."
Read full review ↗
Ankita Chaurasia· Bollywood Life
3.0
"Accept this invitation only if you are really out of your mind or want to kill some time, literally. By the time you walk out of the film you would have lost track of all that is sensible in the world. Consider yourself forewarned."
Read full review ↗
IANS· Sify
3.0
"The 3D effects are unwarranted. As for the special graphic effects, the visual element that stands out is the scene which is designed like a stylized, comic book narrative, giving us a brief insight into Arjun's (Karan Johar) backstory. The film has decent production values and actual IIFA Awards shots are seamlessly meshed into the narrative."
Read full review ↗
2.0
"I still cannot decipher the reason behind this over-120 minute apology of a movie. Is there something I failed to glean from the storyline? Are the proceeds and profits (wishful thinking, methinks) going to charity? Did everyone work on this film for free?"
Read full review ↗
Umesh Punwani· KoiMoi
2.0
"On the whole, this movie does not even fall in the trashy category. Even some of the worst films have unintentional humour, this doesn't even has that to boast of. Please give it a miss and watch Sonu Ke Titu Ki Sweety instead for some genuine comedy."
Read full review ↗
FridayMoviez Reviewer· FridayMoviez
2.0
"Claims to be India's first ever 3d comedy film. God knows what 3-dimensional motion we saw in the film. We are saving 2 hrs of your life by recommending you not to watch this one."
Read full review ↗
Rohit Bhatnagar· Deccan Chronicle
2.0
"The film is a torturous endorsement of IIFA. The only question popping up in your mind is, 'What is it?' Is it a film or a fancy documentary on IIFA Awards in New York. Enter the theatre at your own risk or at least carry a punching bag along with you if you are unfortunate to see it."
Read full review ↗
Manisha Lakhe· NowRunning
1.0
"The movie itself is terribly made. It uses footage from the IIFA awards, showing how stars arrive and are seated and are cheering for something that's happening on stage. It's so terribly inserted, even lay people in the audience can see clearly that it is not shot for the film. And if IIFA paid money to promote their brand, the audience will prove that content, not footage is king. Am sure Karan Johar's cell phone has smarter and more interesting video footage than this awful, awful film."
Read full review ↗
Rohit Vats· Hindustan Times
1.0
"Welcome To New York is totally lost in New York, and looks nothing more than an extended IIFA trailer. It's not worth wasting your time, money, patience and intelligence on this mind-numbing promotional video."
Read full review ↗
"Extremely poor direction and writing from Toleti and Dheeraj Rattan are just the top of the iceberg of this ill-executed film. It doesn't have any flow or sense. Given it's a comedy, I don't think I laughed more than twice the entire movie, thanks to Riteish Deshmukh and his comic timing. Anyhow, this movie was a complete waste of time and the 300 bucks I spent on the ticket. Watch it on your own risk."
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Details

Release Date
23 February 2018
Runtime
118 min
Language
Hindi
Genre
Comedy

User Ratings & Reviews

No ratings or reviews yet — be the first to share your take.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.