TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Beyond the Clouds backdrop

Beyond the Clouds

20 April 2018Hindi2h
out of 10
Mixedlukewarm or divided
Monk Score · 21 scored reviews · 4 not rated

Khatter shines, but Majidi's poverty tale feels hollow and formulaic.

Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: Ishaan Khatter's debut performance
  • Criticised: formulaic narrative and clichéd storytelling

Audience

User score 8.0 out of 10 from 1 rating, not enough ratings for a verdict yet

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 24 critics are saying

Critical reception for Beyond the Clouds is mixed, with scores clustering in the average range and no strong consensus emerging. Ishaan Khatter's debut performance is the most consistently highlighted positive, with several critics also noting Anil Mehta's cinematography and Majidi's visual storytelling. Common criticisms center on a formulaic, clichéd narrative that many felt lacked authenticity and emotional depth, with some reviewers specifically calling out the film's romanticization of poverty and its underwhelming screenplay. Most critics treat it as a lesser entry in Majidi's filmography, an intriguing but flawed experiment rather than a compelling work.

How the 21 scores spread

4 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 24 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (25)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Film Companion

    Film review ·

    Ultimately Beyond the Clouds is a mixed bag.  It is likely to be a footnote in Majidi's rich filmography. But the film is worth seeing as an intriguing experiment. I'm going with three stars.
  2. Top critic

    IBNLive

    Film review ·

    Ultimately the film offers comfort in the familiar…for those that seek it. It's Majid Majidi-lite at best; a bittersweet, inoffensive drama that runs, but never flies. I'm going with a generous three out of five.
  3. Top critic

    Indian Express

    Film review ·

    The bright-eyed Ishaan Khatter has something, a flicker in his eyes, and gets some zest into his part. Malavika Mohanan is great on the eyes, but clueless in how to fill her part.
  4. DNA India

    Film review ·

    Beyond the Clouds should be watched to experience how a master storyteller like Majidi can redeem Hindi cinema from drudgery.
  5. Masala

    Film review ·

    Adapting the  higher scales  from the musical notes, Majid Majidi's symphony on the underbelly of Mumbai plays out  at  an impossibly shrill  pitch without  losing  the core cadence. The director is not alone in  pursuing that pitch-perfect shrillness. Ishaan Khattar knows how that is  done.
  6. Bollywood Life

    Film review ·

    Beyond the Clouds is a must watch for Ishaan Khatter's debut act and Majidi's unique take on the human spirit. It has some beautiful moments that will catch you by surprise. Don't miss this one!
  7. Filmfare

    Film review ·

    Majid Majidi has always conveyed the truth about what's happening in society through his films. He takes a harsh look at the lives of the common people and strives to find beauty beneath the grime.
  8. KoiMoi

    Film review ·

    All said and done, this is a visual representation of alloyed emotions backed by memorable performances of Ishaan Khatter and Malavika Mohanan. Watch this to realise how you can put your life to a better use.
  9. Times Of India

    Film review ·

    Majidi's subject matter might seem to be repetitive, but the famed director's take on redemption is fleshed out by strong performances to make 'Beyond the Clouds' another notable entry in his filmography.
  10. FilmiBeat

    Film review ·

    In a nutshell, Beyond The Clouds may not count among Majid Majidi's best works but it has got enough meat to chew upon. This time, his social criticism in the film doesn't exactly reaches its peak. Still it grabs your attention with Ishaan Khatter's fresh talent, Anil Mehta's captivating visuals and the backdrop of 'aamchi Mumbai'.
  11. Mumbai Mirror

    Film review ·

    It takes a Majidi to rise above the plot and offer audiences hope when things look south. Even here, he's determined to make it stick. It may not be a deep, immersive, dislocating experience one usually has when introduced to unwavering spirits and personal narratives that his cinema has come to be known for. But it's surely reminiscent of his previous work and sparkles up an appetite to revisit them.
  12. Sify

    Film review ·

    Overall, by the end, Beyond the Clouds seems like a forced narrative that tells the tale of the unfortunate siblings who are trying to coexist within their circumstances.
  13. Yahoo

    Film review ·

    'Beyond the Clouds' is definitely worth a watch. If nothing else, Ishaan Khatter's character will make you want to believe in goodness and humanity.
  14. Deccan Chronicle

    Film review ·

    BTC is certainly not a masterpiece of Majid Majidi. It is just another regular story of orphan siblings and their problematic lives. Avoid the pace and plot, the film is high on emotions.
  15. Firstpost

    Film review ·

    An energetic and physically immersed performance compensates partially for an absence of tenor. Mohanan too cannot overcome her rawness and one wonders if this is a fallout of the director's inability to breach the language barrier. Together their effort might be sincere but the effect of a lack of cohesion eschews the very emotional gravitas Beyond the Clouds works so hard to achieve.
  16. Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    Despite excellent symbols and good performances in patches, Beyond The Clouds remains something we have seen and had expected. The uniqueness of the film hardly crosses the crowded bylanes. Majid Majidi's foreign eyes see what all of them see.
  17. India Today

    Film review ·

    Beyond The Clouds isn't a spectacular film and is quite flawed with its occasional underwhelming narrative and storytelling. Yet, there are moments that do leave you with a smile, and at some points, does actually make you think that we can always go beyond the clouds.
  18. Rediff

    Film review ·

    Alternating between brat and boy, deception and decency, Ishaan Khatter speaks with a passion that will be heard Beyond the Clouds...

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

Director

Screenplay

Cinematography

Producer

You may also like

More Hindi films

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.