TheReviewMonk
Judgementall Hai Kya backdrop
26 July 2019Hindi153 min

Judgementall Hai Kya

6.326 reviews
CriticsMixed

Bayesian avg · 26 critic reviews

7.5+ Exceptional · 6.5 Recommended · 5.0 Mixed

6.04 ratings
Users

User Score · avg of 4 ratings

8.0+ Exceptional · 7.0 Recommended · 5.5 Mixed

When Bobby meets her new tenants, a young married couple, their perfectly normal life leaves her really curious. But then a murder takes place and Bobby suspects Keshav has a role to play in the crime.

Critic Consensus

Judgementall Hai Kya receives a broadly positive but divided critical reception, with most reviewers acknowledging it as an ambitious and unconventional psychological thriller. Kangana Ranaut's performance is the most consistently praised element across reviews, with several critics also commending Rajkummar Rao and the film's ability to sustain suspense through an unreliable narrator structure. The screenplay and script depth draw the sharpest criticism, with some reviewers finding the second half indulgent, the thriller mechanics ineffective, or the whodunit logic confused and shallow. A notable strand of reviews highlights the film's treatment of mental illness and its social messaging, though opinions differ on how successfully these elements are handled.

26 reviews · 18 positive · 3 mixed

Praised: Kangana Ranaut's lead performanceCriticised: Weak, shallow second-half script

AI-generated summary of 26 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (26)

Raja SenTop Critic· Hindustan Times
8.0
"Watch this film. As evidenced by a man Bobby sees carrying homilies on placards on a street corner, Judgementall Hai Kya knows the difference between accepting and determining something. It is a film about malicious misdirection, and the validity of our narratives — especially those labelled incorrect. It's okay to jump at a cockroach even if you're the only one who sees it. From the right angle, a bug is a feature."
Read full review ↗
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
6.0
"This is the kind of movie which will sharply divide audiences. And that's as it should be. Once I began seeing it as the murmurings of a different mind, I bought it as a caper, as burlesque, where nothing is as it is. I had problems with some of it, but I really liked the rest of it."
Read full review ↗
Saibal ChatterjeeTop Critic· NDTV
6.0
"What is commendable is that Judgementall Hai Kya delivers the message without turning preachy or self-conscious. The breezy flow of the narrative, which isn't broken until parts of the second half begin to seem a tad indulgent, ensures that we are invested in the plight of the characters all the way through."
Read full review ↗
Anupama ChopraTop Critic· Film Companion
"Judgementall Hai Kya dips and soars. Like Bobby, the film can be exhausting. But like her, it's also a true blue original. And you should give it a shot."
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Life· Bollywood Life
8.0
"Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao already sit on a commendable body of work but JudgeMentall Hai Kya has and will reserve a special place in their filmography. Watch it for their explosive screen presence and counter performance. We are going with 4 stars."
Read full review ↗
7.0
"Despite the appallingly spelled title, Judgementall Hai Kya is to be lauded for de-stigmatising mental illness and spinning an engaging, entertaining yarn while doing so."
Read full review ↗
IndiaTvNews Reviewer· IndiaTvNews
7.0
"Watch it for its uniqueness, and the edge-of-seat thrill. Also, here is Kangana in her most weird avatar till date."
Read full review ↗
Devesh Sharma· Filmfare
7.0
"Rear Window (1954) by Hitchcock made the unreliable narrator narrative popular in Hollywood. Thanks to films like Gone Girl and Girl On A Train, it's getting a resurgence in the West. In Bollywood, the recent Badla gave us an example of how twisted such narratives can be. Judgementall Hai Kya is carrying the torch forward. It's another female centric film that leads you across numerous red herrings before finally reaching the denouement."
Read full review ↗
Zeenews Bureau· Zee News
7.0
"Prakash Kovelamudi's Bollywood debut is worth all the adulation and it goes without saying that Kangana and Rajkummar's performance has truly made the film that it has turned out to be. Go for it folks and let yourself immerse in never-seen-before suspense and horror drama."
Read full review ↗
Sreeparna Sengupta· Times Of India
7.0
"'Judgementall Hai Kya' keeps the element of suspense alive all the way till the end.The film pushes the envelope as a dark,psychological whodunit,with a social message weaved in that can't be ignored."
Read full review ↗
7.0
"Kangana Ranaut's Bravura Performance Steals the Show...Kangana Ranaut once again turns in a bravura performance- sincere, believable and watchable all the time."
Read full review ↗
7.0
"Judgemental Hai Kya is a hugely satisfying, snappy thriller with its 1 hour and 56 minutes running time. Entering Bobby and Keshav's muddled heads is a risk worth taking."
Read full review ↗
Indiatoday Reviewer· India Today
7.0
"The film deserves applause for pushing the envelope of a quirky thriller that goes beyond a basic whodunnit."
Read full review ↗
Sukanya Verma· Rediff
7.0
"Judgementall Hai Kya is a wild move but works because of how assured its cast is before and its crew is behind the camera..."
Read full review ↗
Umesh Punwani· KoiMoi
7.0
"This isn't a normal movie. From its treatment to the narrative, everything screams madness. On a brighter side, the story is strong enough to back the wacky side of it. Kangana Ranaut is definitely the queen, but this deck of cards have multiple aces to offer."
Read full review ↗
Meeta Kabra· Wogma
6.0
"Anyway, as far as addressing mental illnesses goes, Judgementall Hai Kya doesn't do any more harm than already done by Hindi movies, even if it doesn't aim at respecting the affected individuals' fate either. For that, I am grateful. Small mercies. In fact, the social cause is not on its priority list, and it works in the film's favour. It aims to be a thriller and thrill it does not unless you call 2-inch long, flying cockroaches appearing on-screen thrilling."
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Hungama News Network· Bollywood Hungama
6.0
"...is a well-made film with powerful performances from both Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao. At the box office, it will cater mainly to the multiplex frequenting audience."
Read full review ↗
Pinkvilla Team· PinkVilla
6.0
"Judgementall Hai Kya might not be the perfect thriller-comedy, but it's surely an attempt to try something different without being judgemental about the audience's taste."
Read full review ↗
Mayank Shekhar· Mid-Day
6.0
"Whether or not you're easily drawn to this alternate world (let alone its conclusion), what can't be denied is how brilliantly Kanika Dhillon carves out a fine suspense-thriller."
Read full review ↗
Kunal Guha· Mumbai Mirror
5.0
"Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao's film struggles to keep the audience consistently interested..."
Read full review ↗
Anna MM Vetticad· Firstpost
5.0
"If you have not yet seen the film, then know that Judgementall Hai Kya is based on an interesting concept, it is often funny and fascinating, but in the ultimate analysis, it does not make the grade."
Read full review ↗
Mayur Sanap· Deccan Chronicle
4.0
"The film plays out as psychological thriller with many twists and turns, but these twists are more abysmal than real shockers."
Read full review ↗
Namrata Joshi· The Hindu
"Eventually, the film turns out to be Ranaut's assertion that she is much misunderstood, but will live the way she wants to"
Read full review ↗
"Kovelamudi stuffs his scenes with absurdist elements and dark humour, but the script is too shallow to support these devices. At best, "Judgementall Hai Kya?" is an ineffective thriller with an obvious villain."
Read full review ↗
IANS· Sify
"Judgementall Hai Kya has its flaws. The film's novelty factor, however, is simply too tempting to gloss over. Don't be too judgemental about its flaws, and you might just love this one."
Read full review ↗
Nandini Ramnath· Scroll.in
"Strong performances cannot rescue a weak and confused whodunit Prakash Kovelamudi's comedy-tinged thriller stars Kangana Ranaut and Rajkummar Rao."
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Details

Release Date
26 July 2019
Runtime
153 min
Language
Hindi

User Ratings & Reviews

Users6.04 ratings

4 ratings from the community

Community Reviews (3)

YUSept 2019

This psychological thriller has ONE murder, TWO suspects, ONE potential victim, TWO backstories and a lot of ambiguity which sparks thrills and add fuel to this unconventional whodunnit mystery. The writing and the treatment of the film is fresh and astute, Kangana does an impressive job as a patient of acute psychotic disorder, the film flows smoothly throughout having a potential to go beyond the ordinary but then the makers chose to take the easy road back home.

'Judgemental Hai Kya' is the most entertaining thriller I have seen in years. It sparks a fire in the layered genre it belongs to, and at the same time, it has nondearth of emotional psychology. Kangana Ranaut just lives Bobby with a smart obviousness, while Rajkumar Rao is very funny despite being sensible as Keshav, with element humor. Writer Kanika Dhillon proves that she is a woman with a hardcore metal, designing a captivating first half that pretty much stays with you despite an unfunny and largely unrealistic first half. But this is two and a half hours of joyous drive, and Prakash Kovelamudi has designed it with sincerity. It's the most layered, funny thriller I have seen in years, and it is a full-bodied original. I am going as far as to say that after 'Gully Boy' and 'Article 15' it is the best Hindi film of the year.

TEOct 2019

Judgementall Hai Kya (Are You Judgemental?) has been made in a way a five-year-old kid would play with water colours when his parents are not looking and what has indeed resulted in a fancy, colourful, and intriguing painting but is bereft of structure, logic, and element of pity that are so central to it being received well and liked by an audience. TN.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.