TheReviewMonk is back — critic reviews for Indian cinema, aggregated. Read our story →

TheReviewMonk
Kurbaan backdrop

Kurbaan

20 November 2009Hindi2h 35m
out of 10
Mixedlukewarm or divided
Monk Score · 11 critic reviews

A stylish thriller let down by its shallow take on terrorism.

Verdict tier Mixed, lukewarm or divided, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: taut screenplay and lead performances
  • Criticised: simplistic, unconvincing treatment of terrorism

Audience

User score 7.7 out of 10 from 3 ratings, not enough ratings for a verdict yet

Critic consensus

What 11 critics are saying

Critical reception for Kurbaan is mixed, with scores ranging from 40 to 80 and the majority clustering around average. Several critics praised the film's taut screenplay, stylish direction, and performances from its leads, with some finding it an engaging thriller that handles its subject with maturity. However, a notable portion of critics found the film's treatment of terrorism simplistic, flawed, and unconvincing, with some pointing out derivative plotting, logical inconsistencies, and an inability to explore its weighty themes with sufficient depth or gravitas.

How the 11 scores spread

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 11 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (11)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Times Of India

    Film review ·

    Kurbaan sure does strike a chord and sets you thinking on stuff that needs to be sorted out before the new world order - a more humanitarian, less violent - sets in. Don't miss it.
  2. Top critic

    IBNLive

    Film review ·

    Stripped to its bone, Rensil D'silva's Kurbaan is an edge-of-the-seat thriller that seldom loses its grip on your attention. Credible performances from its leads, and a nail-biting screenplay make up for the plot holes that threaten to eat into this otherwise engaging film.
  3. Top critic

    NDTV

    Film review ·

    What if your husband - the man you love and share a home and bed with, turns out to be a terrorist? Kurbaan, produced by Karan Johar and directed by Rensil D'Silva, constructs this unimaginably tortured situation and then squanders it. The film has ambition but it is too flawed and simplistic to explore issues like religion, violence and the politics of terrorism with any conviction or gravitas.
  4. Bollywood Hungama

    Film review ·

    Many storytellers have, in the past, narrated stories about terrorists and their nefarious and despicable plans. But let me state one thing categorically. You haven't watched a more profound, a more thought-provoking, a more dramatic story on this subject before KURBAAN. It's not just the most powerful film to come out of Dharma Productions, it's the most powerful film to come out of the Hindi film industry this year, thus far.
  5. Rediff

    Film review ·

    Kurbaan is bloody smart. In its taut screenplay, stylish photography and good performances by the cast, it keeps you engaged, does not insult your intelligence and avoids getting preachy. And that's saying a lot for a film by a debutant director.
  6. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    Neither preachy nor wanting to make a statement, Kurbaan keeps it simple. It's a thriller that tackles terrorism and the Islamic viewpoint with maturity and depth. Packed with powerful performances, it's a must- watch for its technical brilliance and captivating storyline.
  7. The Economic Times

    Film review ·

    Rensil D'Silva makes a confident debut with his taut grip on the subject and confident direction. Of the few loose ends, Riyaaz's quest to deal with the terrorists without any help from the cops looks both, needlessly heroic and unpersuasive. Also it seems quite improbable that the terrorists do not learn his identity till the climax though he is a popular television reporter. Though the lovemaking song between Saif and Kareena is sensually shot, it is employed to corny effect.
  8. Sify

    Film review ·

    Unlike Khuda Ke Liye where you could sense the filmmaker's urge to put forward a point, Kurbaan is a `terrorist flick', where the Kareena-Saif chemistry will be better liked and talked about than the film's content. Sample Kurbaan if you can forgive the director's `filmy' take on terrorism and can enjoy the thrilling moments and superb performances nevertheless.
  9. Glamsham

    Film review ·

    KURBAAN is NEW YORK. But with a different set of actors. KURBAAN is also SHOOT ON SIGHT, again with different actors. The plot remains the same, the twists and turns fails to surprise you and the end is inevitable. However, here, the love story has been hyped, thanks to Saif Ali Khan and Kareena Kapoor having an off-screen romance as well.
  10. The W14

    Film review ·

    What you may brave through then is a flick neither real or serious enough to be a meditation on global terror, nor sweetly suspended and adequately brain-dead to be Die Hard. It's hard to be both. The hardship shows.
  11. Wogma

    Film review ·

    "All Muslim's are terrorists." In order to prove that the Western world thinks that way, Rensil D'Souza and Karan Johar go that extra mile to showcase the very same thing. And, hopefully inadvertently, complete the circle and cast the despicable stereotype in a deeper mould. Why are good Islamic citizens left out?

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

Hindi films like Kurbaan

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.