TheReviewMonk
Dedh Ishqiya backdrop

Dedh Ishqiya

10 January 2014Hindi2h 32m
out of 10
Recommendedmost critics liked it
Monk Score · 28 scored reviews · 7 not rated

Sharp Urdu wit and strong performances make this a worthy watch.

Verdict tier Recommended, most critics liked it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: writing, dialogue, and performances
  • Criticised: falls short of original Ishqiya

Audience

User score 7.1 out of 10 from 19 ratings, Recommended
Read 4 audience reviews ↓

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 33 critics are saying

Dedh Ishqiya received a strongly positive critical reception, with the large majority of reviewers recommending it as one of the better Hindi films in recent memory. Critics most consistently praised the writing and dialogue, particularly the Urdu-inflected shayari and witty lines crafted by Vishal Bharadwaj and Gulzar, alongside Abhishek Chaubey's direction and the performances of Naseeruddin Shah, Arshad Warsi, and Huma Qureshi. A handful of critics noted that the film falls short of the original Ishqiya's spark, with some pointing to pacing issues, a Tarantino-esque climax that divided opinion, and the absence of Vidya Balan's intensity as factors that prevent the sequel from being fully flawless. A minority dissent came from Komal Nahta, who found the high-flown Urdu dialogue alienating and the film dull for mainstream audiences.

How the 28 scores spread

7 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 33 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (35)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Rediff

    Film review ·

    This is a rare joy. It's a genuinely smart film. It's beautifully, lovingly shot. The music aids the narrative instead of distractingly taking it hostage. It's the most quotable Hindi movie in years. It's a sequel that leaves even a highly original first-part far behind. And, for a film so accessible, it's armed with the most cunning, most delicious twist. It's terrific — and a half. Dedhriffic, then.
  2. Top critic

    MihirFadnavis

    Film review ·

    ...smarter, funnier, richer and way more gorgeous than its predecessor. If you're a fan of really, really great writing, masterful direction, clever lines, terrific actors, Urdu literature and shayari, Dedh Ishqiya delivers by the truckloads. There's a severely satisfying degree of subtext beneath the front layers of Dedh Ishqiya, and homages are only a part of the film's intelligent satirical touches. But don't let metaphors and subtext get you down, Dedh Ishqiya is first and foremost a very entertaining movie. Plus it's got a generous dose of cinematic 'moments', and a terrific special effect – romance between Naseer and Madhuri Dixit.
  3. Top critic

    IBNLive

    Film review ·

    Dedh Ishqiya gives the UP badlands a light cloak of humor and, to the viewer - we're happy to note - a bold reveal that is more suggested than emphasized. The twist in the tale is one you can spot from a mile away, but it's nicely done. I'm going with four out of five for director Abhishek Chaubey's Dedh Ishqiya. Like heady wine, it delivers a welcome kick.
  4. Top critic

    NDTV

    Film review ·

    From dilkashi to junoon, the start and end point respectively of Khalujaan's take on the seven stages of love, the film has them both and everything in between and beyond.
  5. Top critic

    Deccan Chronicle

    Film review ·

    Replete with florid dialogue and competent performances, too, the sequel to Ishqiya (2010) is good to put it plainly, but not quite in the class of the outstanding first edition which was free of, for want of a better word, snafus. Moreover, the earlier femme fatale played by fierce fervour by Vidya Balan, is sorely missed.
  6. Top critic

    TheFrontRow

    Film review ·

    There is a lovely running gag about the stages of love and a gorgeous climactic shoot-out. Best of all, the film gives us women who are unapologetically scheming and lusty. They break all the rules and get away with it. It's wonderfully refreshing. And yet, Dedh Ishqiya doesn't have the seductive sparkle that Ishqiya did.
  7. Top critic

    Indian Express

    Film review ·

    There is much to be liked in the film, and I wish all of it had been as good as the scintillating bits. The trouble is not just with the pace. Some of the lines, terrific as they are, seem to be added in just so that the characters can revel in their own perfect Urdu delivery.
  8. Bollywood Life

    Film review ·

    The costumes, the characters, the cleverness, the construction of each scene…everything about this one is a treat. Yes, the dialogue if often obscure, with the high proportion of Urdu that colours it, but more is said with the eyes than with the tongue, which makes the entire film a pleasure to watch.
  9. Bollywood Hungama

    Film review ·

    ...a worthy follow up to the widely admired ISHQIYA. Powerful writing, superb direction and outstanding performances make DEDH ISHQIYA a must watch. Just don't miss it!
  10. India Glitz

    Film review ·

    'Dedh Ishqyia' is creatively the best continuation of B-town's popular series after Munnabhai. It is vintage, refreshing, stirring, satisfying, witty, edgy, stylish and open-minded, sexy, snaky and oomphy. B.O. may continue to feel proud for its 'Dhoom' by those masala 'Dabangg' entertainers but nothing is cinematically as satisfying as 'Dedh Ishqyia' in the B-town series and desi spaghetti con genre.
  11. India Today

    Film review ·

    Dedh Ishqiya makes desi go dangerous all over again. It's a whopper of a start for Bollywood in 2014. In a line, not to be missed.
  12. KoiMoi

    Film review ·

    Dedh Ishqiya is a sexy film. Mystically poignant, grippingly lucid, dark, subtle and so invigorating-ly well performed. It's not everyday that you stumble upon near perfect films which entertain you so enthralling-ly... Abhishek Chaubey topples the standards he set by his last film Ishqiya and delivers a more intricate and more pioneering work of outright genius.
  13. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    Watch this film; the world outside would have gotten mellower and more beautiful when you come out of the theatre. Why dedh and not do, did you say? Fellini and his 81/2 should perhaps be thanked for that.
  14. Sify

    Film review ·

    There's so much to be savoured in the film -- from the performances, aesthetics, music, and the story itself. You don't watch a film like this, you soak it in!
  15. SKJBollywoodNews

    Film review ·

    It constructs the dynamics of love and redemption from the rubble of a lost world . It gets its indomitable storytelling power from the writing and dialogues. The four principal actors, as well as Vijay Raaz and Manoj Pahwa, imbue broad and bright shades to their fey characters. Here's a world of poetry and parody that never co-existed anywhere else.
  16. The Navhind Times

    Film review ·

    The writers have also pushed the envelope as far as portraying the relationship between the two prime characters is concerned. For those interested in poetry, there is a lot to appreciate here, especially the many verses of Dr. Basheer Badr. Dedh Ishqiya is sight for sore eyes. Go for it.
  17. TimeOut

    Film review ·

    It's dark, sardonic and funny. Don't miss 2014's first great Hindi film. The actors lift up the written material. Naseeruddin Shah and Arshad Warsi carry forward some of the fantastic chemistry they displayed in Ishqiya, both playing off each other's strengths. Madhuri Dixit-Nene fits into the role of a nawabi begum like a hand to glove.
  18. Yahoo! India

    Film review ·

    Abhishek Chaubey's 'Dedh Ishqiya' is entertaining, intriguing and humourous. He sure knows how to tell a gripping story peppered with generous doses of wit.
  19. Zee News

    Film review ·

    With a cast boasting of pro names of showbiz like Naseeruddin Shah, Vijay Raaz, Arshad, Huma and last but not the least, Madhuri, `Dedh Ishqiya` is a dark gem for the connoisseurs of this genre. Madhuri exudes a charming aura on-screen, and Huma rules every frame she appears on. The chemistry between Madhuri and Naseer saab looks a tad forced perhaps because of their wide age gap, but we will go for the madcap tricks cooked up by the duo Babban and Khalu.
  20. BookMyShow

    Film review ·

    Dedh Ishqiya is a royal affair, one that promises to offer you more than your money's worth. Watch out for Shah's Nawab act in the film, Bhardwaj, Gulzar and Chaubey's rustic and raw dialogues, Dixit's Begum act and her Kathak performance.

From our readers

Audience reviews (4)

19 ratings · user score 7.1

  1. sophia ajazJan 2014
    8/10

    Probably, after MUNNA BHAI series' Munna-Circuit jodi, now Khalujaan-Babban have taken over. (Khalu like aalu, bhalu, kaalu, lalu, wagerah, wagerah...) Khalu in Urdu stands for maternal aunt's husband. Such raw and boiling "chemistry" can put the chill out from this winter. Naseeruddin Shah (63, Iftekhar/Khalujaan) by merely being in a frame makes it classic. Arshad Warsi (45, Razzaq Hussain/Babban) is the most under-rated actor, who still hasn't got his due. Had Amitabh invested his billions in Arshad instead of the perennial struggler, he'd've recovered his investment with handsome gains by now. You need to have a sound knowledge of Urdu language to grasp the subtleties and fineries of this beautiful language. Otherwise everything'll go over the head and one may not enjoy the bickerings and tu-tu main-main. Absolutely brilliant. Dialogues are simply delectable. You will remember them long after. Cinematography too is mind-blowing. I know Photoshop is an excellent makeup software. But what should I do when I am against makeup itself. I prefer natural beauty. And what can one say about the Photoshop queen Madhuri (46, Begum Para). She looks like Babban's mother but tries looking like Huma Qureshi (27, Muniya) babe (mother/aunt-niece jodi.) That charming smile isn't the same. Time and again "comebacks" can take its toll. Why can't she rest and watch the younger heroines' movies. After her insensitive and gross Saifai 1-crore nautanki, she may've been consigned to where she should be. She may have "lost" a chunk of her fan-following and wonder if a few hundreds will patronize it. The movie's chances r grim. I pity her and sympathize with her desperation. Women-centred flicks never fared well barring a few. She must have invested heavily in this movie and the next "comeback" GULABI GANG. She is ready to give "tough" competition to TV vampish tai and sasu ma and... Couldn't she learn something from Sadhna!!! I must appreciate her optimism to go on re-inventing herself. I wonder if her kids will know her through her screen presence only as mother is 'shooting'. Shraddha Kapoor and Amrita Puri are in item numbers that are not exactly needed. Although the movie boasts of six songs, none are actually hummable. Vijay Raz (50, Jan Mohammed, politician) is in a class of his own. Words don't do justice to what he brings to screen. Kudos. He is ably assisted by Ravi Gosain (Liyaqat Ali) and Manoj Pahwa (50). Marvellous actors dotting the Indian acting scene instead of the crass moneyed non-actors. '-[ DI may not compete with its prequel ISHQIYA (2010) but it is an excellent encore to male bonding. Naseer-Arshad will win many awards for their roles. They tug at the heart-strings. I will wait for Part 3 too if this male team remains. But they should avoid Photoshop heroines. Makeup stage tak OK hain heroines le le. Har din aisi film nahin aati.

  2. 7/10

    Much like Munna (Sanjay Dutt) and Circuit (Arshad Warsi) are integral part of Munnabhai series, Khalu (Naseeruddin Shah) and Babban (Arshad Warsi) are the integral part of our own Desi crime comedy series Ishqiya. Ishqiya wasn't a crowd pleaser so its sequel Dedh Isqiya also does not aim the masses. Instead with its Urdu dialogs every now and then to support its atmosphere and honest story telling, it requires your patience and attention so that you can enjoy the quirky and intelligent dialogs written by Vishal Bhardwaj. The movie is most enjoyable whenever you witness the electric chemistry between our leads. New actors include another veteran Madhuri Dixit, fierce beauty Huma Qureshi and ultimate performer Vijay Raaj. Vijay Raaz's character must be kept in the story if they are taking the series forward which they should. Movie looses you sometimes during its long Urdu conversations and the tiring and labored performance by Madhuri Dixit. Intelligent crime comedies and black humor are still to find a place in Bollywood hall of fame but Vishal Bhardwaj and his team promises you that they will not compromise and keep serving you with intelligent stories.

  3. 6/10

    Love The Comedy In The Film and The Artistic Way of Love But It Lacked Heart...Storyline is much similar to The Ishqiya..But the comedy is better here, but other things just fade away a little if you compare it with the 1st One..Anyway not a bad watch at all.Love the Use Of Urdu in the Film

  4. 8/10

    Dedh Ishqiya is easily the sexiest film this year. And the title of the film totally justifies the narrative which follows. It is not entirely a sequel. Yes, there are Khalujan and Babban continuing the same task they did previously, but this time they are bound by a tauter, more light backdrop. We have a new story, involving the once-royal people who haven't lost their grandeur. Naseeruddin Shah shows a side of himself as Khalu which was naive to Ishqiya. The film is a visual triumph of colours which comes not only as a thrilling black comedy like the original, but also a sharp rom-com. There are amazing palaces, sweeping ghaghras and mujre ka gharana. There is profound literature and sufi music. On the whole, this is a film that wins over easily. Watch it for Madhuri Dixit, she is a total finesse here. Above, anything 'Dedh Ishqiya' is a more productive narrative than the original, because it celebrates itself with sincerity. I'm going with 4 out of 5 for the film. Its 'Dedh', but for me 'Saadhe Aath'.

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

Hindi films like Dedh Ishqiya

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.