TheReviewMonk
Margarita, with a Straw backdrop
17 April 2015Hindi100 min

Margarita, with a Straw

6.631 reviews
CriticsRecommended

Bayesian avg · 31 critic reviews

7.5+ Exceptional · 6.5 Recommended · 5.0 Mixed

6.111 ratings
UsersMixed

User Score · avg of 11 ratings

8.0+ Exceptional · 7.0 Recommended · 5.5 Mixed

Anne Misawa CinematographyMikey McCleary MusicShonali Bose DirectorShonali Bose Writer

A rebellious young woman with cerebral palsy leaves her home in India to study in New York, unexpectedly falls in love, and embarks on an exhilarating journey of self-discovery.

Critic Consensus

Margarita, with a Straw receives a broadly positive critical reception, with the large majority of reviewers recommending it as an emotionally resonant and thematically bold film. Kalki Koechlin's central performance is the most consistently and emphatically praised element across reviews, with several critics describing it as among the finest female performances in recent Indian cinema; the supporting work of Revathi and Sayani Gupta also draws notable mentions. Critics appreciate the film's unflinching treatment of disability, female desire, and bisexuality, with many noting its honesty and emotional depth. Common criticisms include an overstuffed narrative that attempts to cover too many issues, a weaker second half, and, in isolated cases, a perceived excess of melodrama or an unsatisfying ending.

31 reviews · 20 positive · 2 mixed · 1 negative

Praised: Kalki Koechlin's central performanceCriticised: Overcrowded narrative, weaker second half

AI-generated summary of 31 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (31)

Anupama ChopraTop Critic· Hindustan Times
8.0
"This film is guaranteed to make you cry. But it will also fill you with hope. These amazing women will make you want to inhale life with a new ferociousness."
Read full review ↗
Rajeev MasandTop Critic· IBNLive
7.0
"The film is unafraid to explore touchy themes like female desire and sexual drive of disabled people...Don't miss the film, or you'll miss what is likely one of the year's strongest performances by a female actor."
Read full review ↗
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
6.0
"Kalki pulls it off, and makes us believe in her Laila...This is a film to be celebrated. I am raising a Margarita, as a toast. Now where's that straw?"
Read full review ↗
Subhash K Jha· SKJBollywoodNews
10.0
"The film's emotional affluence is matched by its technical finesse. The art work and locational detailing unfussy and matter-of-fact , as well as the casting of every character is so correct, you wonder how the director got it so right with so little self-congratulations."
Read full review ↗
"Do not pass up a sip of Margarita, With A Straw. It could be life-altering. If nothing else, it will soak you with its warmth."
Read full review ↗
Aashi Gahlot· Bollyspice
8.0
"Margarita, with a Straw is a must watch. The film leaves you with a strong sense of wanting to make this world an equal place for all – isn't that what the power of cinema should be used for in a world rife with inequality?"
Read full review ↗
Srijana Mitra Das· Times Of India
8.0
"The script somewhat over-diligently ticks every possible 'challenge' box, mixed marriages to a Pakistani-Bangladeshi visually affected lesbian. But that small quibble aside, MWAS is deeply moving, a philosophical film which makes you wonder if the body is a palace or prison - and evokes mothers to lovers who've cherished your soul. Try this Margarita - it's different."
Read full review ↗
Kusumita Das· Deccan Chronicle
8.0
"When a film that has a disabled character at its centre, calls itself Margarita With A Straw (and not Chhoone Chali Aasman, as suggested by Taare Zameen Pe's Aamir Khan), you know nothing regular is coming your way. This cocktail is a must-try. And you might just ask for a repeat."
Read full review ↗
Paloma Sharma· Rediff
8.0
"... is a refreshingly, brutally honest film which ends up making the tiny mistake of adding an emotional, clichéd ending. Although certain scenes in the film could have been infinitely more powerful had the background score been stronger, one must laud Bose's use of deafening silence and Laila's wails in a scene at the hospital towards the end of the film."
Read full review ↗
IndiaGlitz· India Glitz
8.0
"Immaculately casted and beautifully heartfelt 'Margarita, With A Straw' is a movie that takes disability with dignity - a highpoint in today's age of Indian cinema giving humanity and choice its good name back with a degree of sophisticated grace. A must for those who understand humanity and good cinema."
Read full review ↗
Rahul Desai· Mumbai Mirror
7.0
"This is a film that attempts to make us comfortable with the viewing and experience of disability, by exposing us to its protagonist's most monotonous and private moments. Charming title aside, Margarita, With A Straw-though a crushing experience deserves to be watched for her."
Read full review ↗
Piyush Chopra· NowRunning
7.0
"...is that rare film that reaches for the stars with its feet firmly on the ground. Honest, soaring, eye-opening and all the while entertaining, Shonali Bose's little gem of a film is well worth the price of an admission ticket this weekend."
Read full review ↗
FridayMoviez Reviewer· FridayMoviez
7.0
"There's a message that the film is trying to portray: to get nothing in the way of you, your life, and your happiness. Go for it this weekend or you definitely are going to miss a good piece of work."
Read full review ↗
Ambarish Ganesh· IndianNerve
7.0
"It is indeed an individual's journey but in so many ways it is also about love and about losing the ones we love. I watched this film alone and realized that I shouldn't have. Go book your tickets and watch it with people you love, I guarantee you won't be disappointed."
Read full review ↗
7.0
"A dash of reality would have given Laila's journey that much more gravitas and credibility. And the film does go a bit off-focus in the second half. But one still recommends the film wholeheartedly! How often in Bollywood do you see a differently-abled bisexual heroine, one who gets to have her own share of flaws, her romantic adventures, and her journey towards self-actualization? This margarita is intoxicating stuff, even if with a straw!"
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Life· Bollywood Life
7.0
"I admit I had more expectations from MWAS, especially after the glowing reviews it had received from almost everyone in Bollywood. But that shouldn't stop me from recommending this movie as a definite must-watch this weekend. After all, don't we always complain about the lack of quality films in Bollywood? Margarita…may not be a masterpiece, but it certainly has its straw…sorry, heart in its right place!"
Read full review ↗
Sachin Chatte· The Navhind Times
7.0
"The acting is from the top draw, along with Kalki, Sayani Gupta and Revathy fit the bill. With a story that comes straight from the heart, Margarita With a Straw is eminently worth a watch."
Read full review ↗
7.0
"The star cast is pretty good. A special mention has to be made of the ever dependable Revathi, who yet again delivers a convincing act. But of course, it is Kalki who takes your breath away with a superlative performance. Undoubtedly with one of the finest performances in recent years, Kalki lives and breathes Laila with such amazing ease and conviction that she stays in your head for a long time after you have left the theatre."
Read full review ↗
Mayank Shekhar· The W14
6.0
"The stories eventually boil down to common emotions. As does this film's. Yes, there is a lot of pathos. But there is much joy. And enough empathy. By the end of it you want to go get a margarita with Laila. How does it matter if she drinks it with a straw? She's just as much fun. Yes, so is this picture."
Read full review ↗
Sweta Kaushal· Hindustan Times
6.0
"Should you go watch this film even if you don't know of any differently-abled person in your life? Yes, of course, mainly because this film reminds us that as a society we shy away from way too many things - be it desires of our differently-abled kids or the sexual orientations."
Read full review ↗
6.0
"...is purely an emotional, slice of life film that will draw you with its simplicity. This is Kalki Koechlin's best performance, watch it for her."
Read full review ↗
Suhani Singh· India Today
5.0
"It is for Kalki's fine performance and Bose's commendable effort to treat its lead just like any other person, we recommend watching Margarita, With a Straw."
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Hungama News Network· Bollywood Hungama
4.0
"...is decent film but it will struggle at the box-office as it caters to a very niche segment of the audience."
Read full review ↗
Martin D'Souza· Glamsham
2.0
"Shonali Bose packs too many emotions into this movie, some unwarranted, which takes away any emotions one might have had as the movie began. Also, she is obsessed with showing Laila (Kalki Koechlin) who is suffering from Cerebral Palsy as this sex maniac!"
Read full review ↗
Deepanjana Pal· Firstpost
"Kalki Koechlin is brilliant in this flawed yet heartfelt film... Ultimately, Margarita With A Straw is a film with a lot of heart and a powerful performance from Koechlin, but you can't help feeling that Laila deserved better."
Read full review ↗
Tanaya Ramyani· BookMyShow
"...is a rare feat. It is rich in all aspects. There is humor, emotion and tension. She perfectly blends all the ingredients and gives us a delightfully fresh film. This Margarita is perfect for your weekend."
Read full review ↗
Anuj Kumar· The Hindu
"Stirred well, Maragarita leaves a heady feeling..."
Read full review ↗
Sanjukta Sharma· LiveMint
"Bisexuality, emotional courage and the pain of loss are Bose's spindles for the story. The setting is important in as much as it shows how a city allows a person with disability freedom and confidence of mobility. We see that Delhi is far behind New York, but not through dialogues or long-drawn scenes."
Read full review ↗
Devesh Sharma· Filmfare
"A little more effort would have turned Margarita With A Straw it into a wonderful film but despite the flaws, it's surely an attempt in the right direction..."
Read full review ↗
JPN· Jagran
"The star cast is pretty good. A special mention has to be made of the ever dependable Revathi, who yet again delivers a convincing act. But of course, it is Kalki who takes your breath away with a superlative performance. Undoubtedly with one of her finest performances in recent years, Kalki lives and breathes Laila with such amazing ease and conviction that she stays in your head for a long time after you have left the theatre."
Read full review ↗
"Only Kalki Koechlin salvages the film in these moments with her understated and sensitive portrayal of a girl who is unabashed about her sexuality and unafraid to explore it. She embodies Laila, and therefore makes her story believable."
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Details

Release Date
17 April 2015
Runtime
100 min
Language
Hindi
Genre
Drama

User Ratings & Reviews

Users6.111 ratings

11 ratings from the community

Community Reviews (3)

Margarita with a Straw, a film by Shonali Bose, explores the life of a Delhi University girl suffering from Cerebral Palsy. This is a motor disorder, which restricts the movement of the person, but does not affect the intellect at all. In our country, unfortunately, every specially-abled individual is either looked at as a result of a curse or an object of pity. This film tells us that every individual is God's own creation and unique in their own manner and beyond any judgment. Shonali brilliantly puts across the story of Laila, a very sharp, talented, intelligent person and a music lover too. Very touchy topics viz. her growing physical and emotional needs, desires, her exploration to ascertain her own sexual preferences, her taking pleasure by visiting porn sites, her lesbian relationship, her being bisexual as well, her infatuations etc. are depicted with great dignity and sensitivity. Simultaneously, Shonali wins the audience' hearts with her portraying a wonderful mother-daughter relationship through her story; a family not discriminating between their two children etc. But, what supersedes is the journey of a girl to become self-reliant who gets absolutely comfortable with her own self, falls in love with self, seeks inner happiness by going on a date with self. Laila (Kalki Koechlin) is brilliant and convincing as a patient of Cerebral Palsy. Initially one struggles to understand her speech but as the frames move further, it becomes easier to understand her speech. How realistic, this is how, it happens in real life as well. She is a Delhi University student who dares to explore her sexual desire with another classmate (a specially-abled boy). She gets infatuated with Nima, a college band singer, and writes lyrics for the band but gets heartbroken when her love is not reciprocated by Nima. Laila wants to escape from the college environment, and to her respite, she gets a scholarship to study in New York University. Shubhangi (Revathi), a very caring and protective mother of Laila accompanies her to USA for making her settled there. Laila falls in love with an young activist. What happens thereafter, how Laila explores her life further, how she evolves into a self-reliant individual, how she fights with the odds / struggles of her life etc. forms rest of the story. Brutally honest Laila surprises you. Revathi is brilliant. Wonderful aspects of mother-daughter relationship are shown. Moments worth mentioning: Laila shares with Shubhangi regarding her first love, her heartbreak, her demand of privacy, expression of her sexual preferences, Laila leaning on the shoulder of Shubhangi while the later sings a classical song etc. Sayani has also justified her character so nicely. Laila is projected like any other normal individual who has different shades to her character - at times selfless, at times selfish, at times manipulative, at times sensitive, at times a rebel.Margarita with a Straw peeks into the complex inner world of Laila sensitively.

LADec 2015

Modern tragedy. Good, Kalki made it more vivid and clear. Her acting is outstanding. Good to watch movie. Faminine world of abnormal women are captured with their desire to walk with the people in general- is the issue of the film. Good one.

SHSept 2019

When was the last time you felt that a character deserved a film, and not any better one? When was the last time you cried watching a film? I, for one, remember myself sobbing in wonder, watching Margarita with a Straw. Directed by the gifted filmmaker Shonali Bose, who directed Chittagong and the highly censored Amu earlier, this is a heartwarming film which celebrated the cerebral palsy and the lead, who is affected by this, Laila. Kalki Koechlin is terrific as Laila, easily pulling off one of the best performances this year. The storytelling is animated and restrained, shifting gazes and ultimate observations. I suggest you watch 'Margarita with a Straw', because not only does it celebrate its protagonist, it writes her as a progressive female in these times of rapid regression. It is the film we need, I am going with 4 stars.

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.