Login to TheReviewMonk

Paltan

Paltan Poster

Critic Rating

3.8

12 Reviews
11 Ratings
18%
in favor

Audience Rating

3.0
1 Review
1 Rating

Movie Info

Director

Language

Hindi

Synopsis

A war drama based on the Indo-China War of 1962, JP Dutta's "PALTAN" focuses on the hard-hitting truth of India's relations with China, and how it is important to acknowledge that China, an enormous power in world politics, poses to be a huge threat to India.Wikipedia

Paltan Reviews

4

It’s got a tired, recycled feel to it, and fails to hold up to Dutta’s better films.

Raja Sen
Hindustan Times

3

There is a lot to be said about the futility of war, and now Dutta has made his case for the futility of the war movie. Starring Arjun Rampal, Sonu Sood and others.

Anupama Chopra
Film Companion

4

J.P. Dutta’s film, based on a military operation against the Chinese at the Nathu La Pass in Sikkim in 1967, is structurally clumsy, bland and flat-out tedious

Shalini Langer
Indian Express

3

All sound and fury signifying nothing...J P Dutta's Paltan doesn’t allow JP Dutta his usual blood and gore and glory of war.

Deccan Chronicle Team
Deccan Chronicle

2

JP Dutta gives his best to lend authenticity by using the real terrain but after an hour of the movie it is like deja vu.

J P Dutta's clownish treatment of history and hard-earned triumph demeans the efforts and sacrifices of real-life martyrs and bravehearts with its pompous ideas of valour, clunky writing and a cadre of lacklustre actors...

Reviewer Profile
Times Of India

6

Paltan manages to undo some of the damage in its final moments that are truly action packed. Director JP Dutta fires all his ammo in a rousing climax for a bitter sweet victory.

DNA Web Team
DNA India

6

Paltan is definitely worth a watch as it relives India's 1967 triumph over China and rouses our patriotic feelings.

3

For a story that hasn't been attempted on celluloid so far, Paltan could have been interesting. Unfortunately, it is high on desh bhakti and low on the content in the script

Paltan is more testosterone and male ego than strategy or drama and, surprisingly, it’s tentative even in its jingoism.

IANS
Sify

5

The film is packaged with excellent production values, but overall, this is just another derivative of Dutta's film Border in a fresh avatar.

-

It’s difficult to tell if Paltan is a war film or a long-drawn advertisement for the armed forces...

Audience Reviews for Paltan

  • Midhun Ben Thomas (Dilseben)
    Midhun Ben Thomas (Dilseben)
    160 reviews
    Top Reviewer
    3

    Paltan review: "Weakest among Dutta's war trilogy!!!"

    Whenever we speak about war movies, there are quite a few that instantly comes to mind instantly such as "Saving Private Ryan", "Hurt Locker", "Dunkirk" etc., to name a few. In general, it would be fair to admit that Hollywood has always done an impressive job in crafting such war drama. Unfortunately, the same yard stick cant be applied to Indian movies as we haven't explored much in that genre & among the ones that were picturised, "Border" was definitely my favorite. So when it was announced that J.P Dutta was back with yet another war saga, "Paltan" I was eager to check it out. The question was whether Dutta still had the goods to deliver another gritty movie???



    As history says, our nation suffered a crushing defeat in the hands of China in the war of 1962. This included documented reports as to how the Chinese resorted to dishonorable war tactics to defeat the famed Rajput regiment. About five years has passed but the tension between the nations shimmered at the border which led to constant skirmishes between the armies. Lt Col Rai Singh (Arjun Rampal) & his battalion was entrusted with the task of protection of Nathu La region from possible Chinese incursions. With the Chinese constantly needling his forces with the construction of bunkers & other structures into our land, Col Rai orders fencing to to be laid along the perceived border. As expected, this irks the Chinese & it eventually blown out into a full fledged war. So did our Army finally have their revenge for 1962???



    J.P Dutta is an individual who needs no introduction with movies like "Border", "LOC:Kargil" to his credit. However, he has been keeping a low profile in recent times with his last release being the forgetful "Umrao Jaan", more than a decade back. Apart from direction, he has also taken on the responsibility of the script & screenplay; all of which were below par to be frank. He had a compelling tale to narrate but he wasnt able to do justice to it as the conflict between the nations portrayed here seemed more like kids fighting in school. The dialogues at most instances were short slogans & the people who mouthed them didnt even an iota of expression of them. Unlike his previous war dramas which had charismatic actors, over here we are left with a bunch of earnest individuals including experienced campaigners who struggles to capture our attention. The age old problem in Indian movies of portraying foreigners like British, Pakis etc as dimwits & with a single shade in their character is repeated yet again with the Chinese portrayed as an easily agitated school bully. On the technical side, Shailesh Awasthi & Nigam Bomzan has captured the locales pretty well while Anu Malik's music was average at best.



    None of the known names like Jackie Shroff & Arjun Rampal were worthy of their roles as they seemed disinterested & even a robot could have delivered the dialogues as well as them or maybe even better. Among the rest, Harshvardhan Rane as Major Harbhajan Singh has done a fine job along with Gurmeet Choudhary while Sonu Sood was ok.



    Verdict: Without mincing words, I would have to say that this movie doesn't have working in its favour & is destined to tank at the box office. Except for the emotional scenes that unfold towards the end, there is nothing else that would even remotely make us empathize with the movie. In short, forget it!!!



    Rating: 1.5/5



    Regards...Ben

    September 14, 18