TheReviewMonk
Brothers backdrop
14 August 2015Hindi155 min

Brothers

4.838 reviews
CriticsUnfavorable

Bayesian avg · 38 critic reviews

7.5+ Exceptional · 6.5 Recommended · 5.0 Mixed

4.99 ratings
UsersUnfavorable

User Score · avg of 9 ratings

8.0+ Exceptional · 7.0 Recommended · 5.5 Mixed

David and Monty, estranged half-brothers, train in mixed martial arts to earn a livelihood. However, things change when the two are forced to compete against each other in the final tournament.

Critic Consensus

Critical reception for Brothers was largely mixed to negative, with most reviewers finding it a pale and over-bloated imitation of its Hollywood source material, Warrior. Akshay Kumar's performance and the MMA fight sequences were the most consistently cited positives across reviews. Common criticisms centered on excessive melodrama, a slow and overlong runtime, weak scripting, and a failure to build meaningful emotional connect between characters. A number of critics explicitly recommended watching Warrior instead.

38 reviews · 9 positive · 12 mixed · 7 negative

Praised: Akshay Kumar's performance and fightsCriticised: Excessive melodrama and poor script

AI-generated summary of 38 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

Critic Reviews (38)

Rajeev MasandTop Critic· IBNLive
5.0
"Brothers, despite its contrivances, leaves you choked more than once. How can it not, with all that unabashed emotional manipulation? Throwing in an item song, repeated flashbacks, and too many cutaways of an anguished wife (Jacqueline Fernandez), Malhotra lays it on thick to a premise already inherently melodramatic. He's further Bollywood-izing a plot that's already 'too Bollywood' to begin with. The result is a film that's trying a little too hard."
Read full review ↗
Shubhra GuptaTop Critic· Indian Express
4.0
"Akshay Kumar, Sidharth Malhotra's film uses a form of kinetic martial arts to foreground its story of two warring siblings, but it stays, at heart, a Karan Johar film."
Read full review ↗
Raja SenTop Critic· Rediff
3.0
"Weighing 158 unbearable minutes, Brothers is nearly 600-times as long as the Rousey win -- and not one-millionth as thrilling."
Read full review ↗
Subhash K Jha· SKJBollywoodNews
8.0
"Brothers may not appeal to those who look for laughter in times of despair.There is barely room for a whiff of a smile in this dark sanguinary and seductive tale of destruction and redemption told in a free-wheeling style that accommodates derivations and innovations without apology or awkwardness. Definitely one of Akshay Kumar's glorious achievements."
Read full review ↗
Ananya Bhattacharya· India Today
7.0
"Akshay Kumar needs to do more of these high-action roles. And not necessarily the mindless action. Watch Brothers for the kicks, punches, grappling, chocking and the un-understandable MMA jargon. You'll come out with the Akshay you want to see, hopefully. Welcome back to the cage, Khiladi Kumar!"
Read full review ↗
Bollywood Hungama News Network· Bollywood Hungama
6.0
"BROTHERS is a huge letdown on the account of its slow pace and lack of emotional connect. At the box office, the movie will enjoy huge footfalls over the weekend due to Independence Day Holiday and lack of credible opposition at the cinema halls. The real struggle for the film however will start from Monday onwards, which would turn out to be the deciding factor of the fate of the film."
Read full review ↗
Tushar Joshi· Bollywood Life
6.0
"Brothers is a decent watch, but if you want your money's worth, then I recommend watching the original Warrior."
Read full review ↗
Priyanka Prasad· FilmiBeat
6.0
"This movie is for both family and youth! Although the youth would enjoy it a tad bit more as Akshay and Sidharth give you one of the best Bollywood action scenes ever. Brothers makes for one great weekend watch, that you just ought to see! So don't miss, book your tickets right away!"
Read full review ↗
6.0
"A background score with lower decibel levels and smarter dialogues might have made this a better film. But still a good one time watch, especially if you are a fight junkie."
Read full review ↗
Srijana Mitra Das· Times Of India
6.0
"Brothers, despite mouthing, 'Har sport mein thora drama toh hota hai', only skims that dramatic surface. It could've dived in deeper."
Read full review ↗
Sarita Tanwar· DNA India
6.0
"It's nowhere close to Warrior. But there's the Akshay-Siddharth on-screen combo, how can you miss that?"
Read full review ↗
6.0
"The few gripping fights, Akshay Kumar's ace act, and a fabulous supporting cast makes the film reasonably watchable. Oscillating wildly between a sports movie and a melodrama, this is your dose of punch-drunk love!"
Read full review ↗
Rohit Vats· Hindustan Times
5.0
"Karan Malhotra's Brothers is not Warrior. It relies heavily on the formula-driven content. Having said that, Brothers still offers you some fantastic fight sequences and a matured Akshay Kumar. You can also consider it a new film rather than a Warrior remake and be happy about it."
Read full review ↗
Dhriti Sharma· Zee News
5.0
"Making the soft hearted audience a bit teary towards the end, 'Brothers' wraps up on a positive note, well, yes the typical Bollywood style. It's dragging climax makes you a little weary, and that is a major setback. This monsoon weekend, go grab a ticket and watch some incredible acting with a hint of breathtaking fight sequences."
Read full review ↗
5.0
"I don't know what I disliked more, Sidharth's incompetency to perform in a role that Tom Hardy completely nailed or the extremely loose plot that is a shoddier version of Warrior. Call for a DVD of Warrior and watch it! Unless over-the-top drama is your scene, you will not enjoy Brothers"
Read full review ↗
IndiaGlitz· India Glitz
5.0
"'Brothers' is a big disappointment. The easy, uninspiring, simple, obvious and boring remake of Hollywood's 'Warrior' struggles to deliver as an action packed emotional family drama even after a terrific Akshay and reformed Sidharth. Still you can watch it if you are an Akshay, Sidharth die hard. Else take your call."
Read full review ↗
FridayMoviez Reviewer· FridayMoviez
5.0
"...despite the fact that the film gets a little bit stretchy in bits and parts, we are going for a two and a half stars for 'Brothers' since the three leading stars Akshay, Sidharth and Jackie carry the film quite well on their shoulders and also full marks to the realistic combat and training sequences. While there is nothing very different or special in the storyline of the film, it is still worth a watch, especially if you want to see Jackie Shroff in one of his best performances and if you are a die-hard fan of mixed martial arts."
Read full review ↗
Sachin Chatte· The Navhind Times
4.0
"Partly being a martial art film, by the time all the arm twisting, skull smashing and bone twisting is over, you are brain dead."
Read full review ↗
4.0
"If you are a die-hard Akshay Kumar fan, and enjoy wrestling matches, this movie might impress you. If not, you can definitely skip watching this one."
Read full review ↗
Martin D'Souza· Glamsham
4.0
"There is in fact no story, nor any story-telling craft. However, if you have braved the first half, and are willing to sit through the next, and love some adrenalin rush, sans any connection with the story, the movie gets better."
Read full review ↗
Kunal Guha· Mumbai Mirror
4.0
"Director Karan Malhotra has a unique ability. He can douse anything into a tub of glycerine and make even a movie about MMA into one about loving your parents. After all, it's also about loving your producer."
Read full review ↗
4.0
"Brothers, despite being a powerful story, lost the plot in the telling. I suggest get a DVD of Warrior instead."
Read full review ↗
Sukanya Verma· Rediff
3.0
"What you get is an earnest Khiladi sporting his graceful greys in a movie that's too cosmetic, loud and exhausting to take notice."
Read full review ↗
BollySpice Editors· Bollyspice
3.0
"Brothers is a series of solid fight scenes that'll make you cringe in sympathy at their realism, thoroughly ruined by an amateurish attempt at drumming up family drama and tons of needless exposition. Filmmakers take the 2011 Hollywood mixed martial arts movie Warrior and instead of building upon it, they totally muddle it."
Read full review ↗
Suparna Sharma· Deccan Chronicle
3.0
"Oho! But we've done this before. Many times. So many times. Family. Bichde bhai... Same-to-same. Ok-ok. Let's do different. Make them Christian. Boxers. Ya! But how will audience samjho? Tattoos. Many. Very many. And Cross. Everywhere."
Read full review ↗
Suhani Singh· India Today
3.0
"Brothers is supposed to be an action drama but it ends up being an action comedy. Characters cry here at the drop of a hat. That's because three leading males have a lot of issues."
Read full review ↗
"It makes so much noise that any sensible point about brotherly bonding and filial fidelity that it might be trying to make is completely drowned out by the decibels. Take your earplugs along."
Read full review ↗
Meeta Kabra· Wogma
3.0
"...films like Brothers need a certain amount of drama to accentuate the action. Such action to make sense in a film need an emotional hook too; else it will feel like you are watching a game on TV. But, this combination didn't work here. All you can recommend it for is the fight sequences when the film is on TV."
Read full review ↗
Shishir Gautam· NowRunning
3.0
"Brothers could have worked better with better editing and lesser of the forced melodrama. What it becomes is a lackluster piece of cinema despite some very hard work put in by the actors."
Read full review ↗
2.0
"Watching Karan Malhotra's 'Brothers' is like déjà vu. It's like re-watching the worst of the '70s – this film is as cliché-ridden as it can be. It has it all - a drunken father jailed for killing his wife, sparring stepbrothers, token Muslim characters (who readily mouth Insha Allah) and dialogues that make the ears bleed. You can give 'Brothers' a complete miss, and you wouldn't have missed anything at all."
Read full review ↗
"There are so many unnecessary elements in "Brothers" that every time you hear the sickening crunch of a bone being broken in a fight sequence, you wish Malhotra had stuck to reproducing the original. If it ain't broke, don't fix it."
Read full review ↗
Udita Jhunjhunwala· Scroll.in
"'Brothers' is a melodramatic remake that is high on style, low on subtlety..."
Read full review ↗
Sneha May Francis· Emirates247
"The spectacular scenes are restricted to the fighting ring. But, unlike Rocky Balboa's bloody boxing adventures, David and Monty's martial arts doesn't inspire or demand applause."
Read full review ↗
Deepanjana Pal· Firstpost
"A few more films like Brothers and Bollywood will have achieved what no amount of litigation can manage — the freedom to copy freely. Because if Gavin O'Connor, who directed and co-wrote Warrior, ever sees how his story has been brutalised, he might just go on a campaign claiming that intellectual property rights be damned, Hollywood is better off not being associated with Bollywood remakes."
Read full review ↗
Uday Bhatia· LiveMint
"Brothers, directed by Karan Malhotra (Agneepath), doesn't have the heart problem; if anything, it exposes a bit too much of its heart. It does have the script problem, the acting problem and several other problems besides."
Read full review ↗
Komal Nahta· Komal Nahta's Blog
"Brothers, a mixed martial arts film, may carry mixed reports but it will ultimately prove to be a paying proposal for all concerned. It will do good business in multiplexes and single-screen cinemas, and in 'A', 'B', 'C' and 'D' class centres. The national holiday tomorrow will see collections take a huge jump."
Read full review ↗
Anuj Kumar· The Hindu
"The problem is, be it emotion or action, Karan is in no hurry to say cut. At times it works for the emotion to seep in but many times over elaboration dilutes the punch. The music is a let down."
Read full review ↗
Rachit Gupta· Filmfare
"Brothers offers a whole new experience to MMA action. Hindi audiences will enjoy the novelty. But all said and done, this should've been done with a lot more finesse"
Read full review ↗

Cast & Crew

Cast

Details

Release Date
14 August 2015
Runtime
155 min
Language
Hindi
Genres
Drama, Action

User Ratings & Reviews

Users4.99 ratings

9 ratings from the community

Community Reviews (3)

GAAug 2015

Hello All, Yesterday i watched this movie. Story was predictable and somehow weak. Jackie shroff comebacks with a super act. The end was also not that great and movie was enjoyable for only 1 hour. regards,

TEAug 2015

2015 has been a terrible year for Hindi cinema. The official remake of the hit Gavin O'Connor film Warrior (2011), Brothers is a solid example to prove that the previous statement is, in fact, true. An alcoholic martial arts trainer (Shroff) accidentally commits a crime that sees his whole family fall apart, giving rise to a rivalry between his two sons, which is irreverently taken inside a wrestling ring. The revelation that one of the two sons was born out of wedlock was the cause of the crime, and continues as a driving cause of the whole story. Now all grown up, David (Kumar), the elder son, is battling for a better pay as a high school teacher, moonlighting as a fighter, to fend for his daughter's critical disease while Monty (Malhotra), alcoholic junior and chip off the old block, is still not over his decades-long familial issues and does specifically nothing for a living. In an international mixed martial arts championship that blooms out of nowhere, David and Monty fight it out through the tough line- up to end up in a one-on-one finale. I can disclose anything and everything about the film and no one can accuse me of being a spoilsport, because the title itself blurts it out loud what and how the film's climax is going to roll out. There is a lot of melodrama before things actually start to make sense, and by the time it culminates with a predictable ending, one wonders what the film was really about. Was it about the rivalry? Was it about the blood relation? Was it about fooling the audience? The happenings inside the ring are literally unbelievable and while most films in this genre try to wrap it up sooner, this one here has the whole second act dedicated to it. Although the production design is greatly supportive, the fights happen back-to-back, where these so-called supermen flex few muscles and show like they toil harder than Chilean miners by eventually winning. And they want us to believe that. Arr, not happening. Shroff acts fine, but is too loud for his dull character. Malhotra looks confused and seems to be thinking about why he chose the project. Kumar looks hungover from playing the notorious vigilante in his previous Bollywood potboiler Gabbar is Back (2015). BOTTOM LINE: Brothers is a faintly engaging family drama attached with a random sport. Avoid. VERDICT: 4 stars out of 10. Another remake bites the dust. Can be watched with a typical Indian family? YES

On the auspicious occasion of our Independence Day, I would like to remind all my fellow Indians that we should strive to keep our freedom intact & not vile it away over petty issues like politics, communal violence etc. It might seem ironic but this week we have Karan Malhotra's "Brothers" hitting the screens which has a pair of brothers baying for each other's blood almost similar as to how some anti-social elements are trying to entice violence against our brothers & sisters. So will the movie cater to the tastes of the Indian audience??? Gary Fernandes (Jackie Shroff), an ex-fighter was released from jail after having served a jail sentence for the accidental murder of his wife. He was filled with remorse as he choked with guilt over the mishap that had happened primarily due to his addiction to alcohol. But it had virtually wrecked the life of everyone in his life as his two sons faced the brunt of it. His elder son, David (Akshay Kumar) who never forgave his father & cut off ties with his half brother after the demise of his mother was leading a contended life as a teacher with his wife & daughter. But a life threatening cardiac problem for his daughter meant he was squeezed for money & was forced to make some extra bucks through street fights. Monty (Sidharth Malhotra) was Gary's younger son who also made a living through fights & like his father was reliant on booze. It was around this time that Peter Bregenza (Kiran Kumar), a multi millionaire sports enthusiast arranges a MMA competition in the country & as one would expect both brothers enroll in it. But who will emerge victorious & at what cost??? Karan Malhotra is familiar to all of us as the one who had remade "Agneepath" which was quite a decent effort to be frank, Over here, he has taken the plot from the Hollywood movie "Warrior" & added heavy doses of melodrama to the point that it gets nauseating in certain sequences. The first half is interspersed with flash backs to showcase the equation between the father & his sons, while in the second half it had nothing apart from fights. So was it an absolute bore??? Well not exactly, as some sequences like the training sessions & fights were well choreographed. But unless you have a decent story to explain, it gets taxing after a certain time which is what happens here, None of the technical aspects deserves special mention as it was average at best. Though Karan might have faltered in the script, I felt he has done a credible job with the cast that he has chosen. Akki was an apt choice as a brother who excels in martial arts & he has enacted his role with restraint making sure he didnt go over the top. Sidharth also has done a fine job as Monty & excelled in the fight sequences, though he needs to work on the emotional scenes. Jackie hams it big time in many of the scenes while Shefali Shah rocked in her brief role. Verdict: It might sound surprising but I actually liked it more than the original but is it worth the time??? Hmm...well I have to say no...coz the script is as predictable as the conduct of our opposition party in Parliament. In all probability, it isn't going to make much of a tremor at the box office & you may as well spent this weekend watching Saina Nehwal's finals!!! Rating: 2.25/5 Regards...Ben

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.