TheReviewMonk
Filmistaan backdrop

Filmistaan

6 June 2014Hindi1h 57m
out of 10
Recommendedmost critics liked it
Monk Score · 19 scored reviews · 5 not rated

Warm, funny, and carried by two fine performances, despite a shaky second half.

Verdict tier Recommended, most critics liked it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.

  • Praised: lead performances and emotional humor
  • Criticised: predictable, undercooked second half

Audience

User score 6.3 out of 10 from 15 ratings, Mixed
Read 2 audience reviews ↓

Not streaming in India

Critic consensus

What 24 critics are saying

The critical consensus on Filmistaan is overwhelmingly positive, with most reviewers recommending it as a refreshing, heartfelt film that punches well above its modest budget and star-free cast. Critics most frequently praised its balance of humor and emotion, its exploration of India-Pakistan relations through a shared love of cinema, and the central performances from Sharib Hashmi and Innamulhaq. The most common criticism is that the film's second half loses momentum, becoming predictable and failing to fully realize its considerable premise. A minority of critics noted unrealized potential, though nearly all still recommended the film as worth watching.

How the 19 scores spread

5 not-rated reviews aren't plotted

Positive / mixed / negative reviews

Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10

AI-generated summary of 24 critic reviews · may contain errors

Report inaccuracy

From the papers

Critic reviews (24)

Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated

  1. Top critic

    Hindustan Times

    Film review ·

    Don't be put off by the name or the lack of stars. This is a lovely little film that will sneak into your heart.
  2. Top critic

    IBNLive

    Film review ·

    'Filmistaan' works best as a movie about the magic of movies. It's a celebration of India's song-and-dance film culture and heightened emotions... one that unites fans in their shared love for this unique art-form. For its sheer inventiveness and for some terrific comic moments, this film is worth a watch.
  3. Glamsham

    Film review ·

    FILMISTAAN is a film that cannot be missed. Watch it for its storyline. Watch it for its execution. Watch it for its many excellent performances.
  4. Rediff

    Film review ·

    Filmistaan is packed with great background scores, unfaltering narration and stellar performances. It's also one of the best films I've watched since Queen and D-Day; it's absolutely flawless.
  5. SKJBollywoodNews

    Film review ·

    This quirky charmer from first-time director Nitin Kakkar is fresh in vision and enchanting in execution.The only happy outcome of the cross-border divide is a heartwarming film such as this.As we often say about the Wagah border, this you gotta see.
  6. Bollywood Hungama

    Film review ·

    FILMISTAAN walks the tightrope between offbeat and commercial with gusto. This is a massively entertaining film. A film that shouldn't be missed at all. Watch it. Now.
  7. Gulf News

    Film review ·

    The film is refreshing and delivers a message of harmony and friendship through laughter and films instead of drawn-out preachy or melodramatic dialogues, proving that we do have some really talented newcomers in the industry. All we need to do is bring them forth. Don't miss it
  8. India Today

    Film review ·

    The film has a perfect balance of humour, seriousness and emotions. The film beautifully defines the relationship between India and Pakistan and forces us to re-think about the baselessness of our sour bi-lateral relations.
  9. KoiMoi

    Film review ·

    Nitin Kakkar's Filmistaan is a crackling movie to the core that doesn't give you one dull moment in its lambent tapestry. Sharib Hashmi is precocious for a debutant and along with Innam's adept performance, the duo deliver a effulgent film. I, for one, didn't get enough of the film and can't wait to pay the price and watch it again.
  10. NowRunning

    Film review ·

    Filmistaan is also a step ahead for the film industry. Of course it would have of been better had it managed to make it to the theaters in time to celebrate the centenary celebrations of Indian cinema. But it's never too late for the good! Jai cine-maa ki! Filmistaan is a movie recommended for one and all!
  11. Sify

    Film review ·

    Do not miss this National Award-winning tragicomedy. Such cinematic gems, both entertaining and poignant, come by rarely!
  12. Times Of India

    Film review ·

    In a nation of star-worshippers, this film devoid of superstars brilliantly stands out. Aaj khush toh bahut hain hum! Ab bas, tareef pe tareef ...
  13. BookMyShow

    Film review ·

    Brilliant in conception and execution, Filmistaan, will entertain you right from the beginning. Filmistaan also delivers a positive message on life. No matter how difficult a situation you are stuck at, always be positive and face the hurdles with a little bit of humor. And yes, always be a little filmy. It helps.
  14. DNA India

    Film review ·

    Fresh and funny, this is a small film with a big heart. Shot on a shoe-string budget, and no star power, Filmistaan relies on it's script and its actors to carry the film. And they both do a wonderful job. Both Sharib and Innamulhaq are perfectly cast and delight with their performances. The developing friendship between the two is captured beautifully. Sunny's obsession with Bollywood is something that most people will relate to. If you are a Bollywood fan, you cannot miss this one.
  15. Mid-Day

    Film review ·

    A story with great potential, it could have been better. But watch it anyway because its simplicity is beautiful.
  16. India Today

    Film review ·

    Filmistaan depends far too much on its hero to control the proceedings. The climax drags as one awaits Sunny's fate. As a film recognising the influence of cinema, Filmistaan is engaging, but not as a kidnapping thriller.
  17. Wogma

    Film review ·

    The real problem then comes with the second half which isn't explicitly downhill either. It's just that it becomes a little predictable with characters taking clichéd routes. Four characters, four clichés. And as many predictable turn of events as there are situations. The fun yet satirical moments gradually deteriorate into "oh we left out this obvious point." And that drops Filmistaan from a 'do not miss' to 'watch when you can'. And that's as saddening as the beginning was heartening, because it hurts to not like a film like Filmistaan.
  18. Mumbai Mirror

    Film review ·

    It is still worth a watch, at least for a genuinely unique protagonist that almost overshadows a botched-up final act.
  19. Emirates247

    Film review ·

    For an (almost) all new cast and first-time director, it's commendable how 'Filmistaan' creates a vibrant frame in spite of relying (rather heavily) on the clichéd Bollywood dream. So, head to the cinemas, you won't regret it.

From our readers

Audience reviews (2)

15 ratings · user score 6.3

  1. 6/10

    Filmistaan, a film by Nitin Kakkar (his debut film), a tribute to Film Industry for its completion of 100 years of cinema. Before its official release on 6th June, 2014, it has won many accolades and awards during various cine festivals (Refer a subheading 'Awards' towards the end of this review). Partition could just divide the land, but people's hearts still remain united. People across the border love watching Bollywood films, it is a great source of entertainment for them. People appreciate the work of artists irrespective of their nationality, rather the fans exist everywhere. Essence of this movie is that a film, its characters, overall this form of art can spread love amongst people, can remove the fences. Nitin has highlighted Indo-Pak cross-border issues but he also projects that people still feel connected with one another. Will we ever get back our old days of togetherness? The movie begins with an aspiring Bollywood actor Sunny aka Sukhwinder Arora's (Sharib Hashmi) audition for a chocolate advertisement. Although Sunny is not able to get through audition, he gets an opportunity to be an assistant director for an American film crew shooting a documentary in Rajasthan (Indo-Pak Border), for which he travels outdoor along with them. A militant group mistakenly kidnaps Sunny instead of Americans, and make him hostage in a small village in Pakistan in Aftaab's (Inaamuihaq) house. Aftaab, a peddler of pirated DVDs, is a great movie buff, who dreams of making his own film one-day. Aftaab and Sunny hit it off instantly due to common thread between them – Bollywood Movies. Even amidst crisis and gun-toting terrorists around, Sunny's love for cinema remains intact. He does not lose his sense of humour. He entertains children with his mimicking various artists. He is passionate about his camera (which was with him when he was kidnapped). The mood of the movie never gets grim in spite of the unfavourable situations. The scene where Sunny directs his own ransom video, and insists upon multiple takes is just hilarious. Another scene, where Aftaab does a screening of Maine Pyar Kiya for the villagers, a segment comes where no audio is there due to poor quality of that pirated DVD. Sunny rattles off those lines effortlessly, a very enjoyable scene. It is so touching to watch the camaraderie between Sunny and Aftaab. What all events unfold? Is Sunny ever able to come back to India? To what extent Aftaab and Sunny bond? Is Sunny able to make a bond with militants as well? Which one amongst the two win – love or hatred / anger? Does love take precedence over hatred? Both Sharib and Inaamulhaq have given brilliant, simple, natural and endearing performances. I just felt that the end could have been clearer. But yes definitely, this movie deserves your watch.

  2. 6/10

    Filmistaan is easily one of the best films about movies in Bollywood, but unlike most of the films of this kind, its not in Bombay that it is set. The film is set in borders of India and Pakistan, where superstars and classics are worshipped like gods and temples. It has humour and a little sensation, but it is a very simple film with warmth which you must embrace whenever you watch. Let me warn you the film has a forgettable second half despite its memorable performances. Post-interval too, some moments feel like pure drags. But it stays with you as long as you keep watching it- watching the movies- and be in your mind too. I'm going with 3 out of 5 for 'Filmistaan'. You need to watch it because it is easily one of the best Hindi films this year which transcend the borders of limitless storytelling, be it literally, be it the metaphor. Strong it is, and so is it simple.

Credits

Cast & crew

Cast

You may also like

More Hindi films

TMDB

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.