Top critic
Hindustan Times
Film review ·
Tiger Shroff, Ananya Panday and Tara Sutaria star as a new batch of students/professionally bred actors in sequel to Karan Johar's 2012 film.


A stale, borrowed school-sports story saved only by Tiger Shroff's dancing feet.
Verdict tier Unfavorable, most critics didn't like it, on a scale of Unfavorable, Mixed, Recommended, Exceptional.
Not streaming in India
Critic consensus
Critical consensus on Student of the Year 2 is overwhelmingly negative, with most reviewers finding the film formulaic, clichéd, and dated in its storytelling. The sole aspect that drew consistent, if limited, praise was Tiger Shroff's physicality and dancing ability, with several critics noting his performance as the film's primary reason to watch. Common criticisms included a weak and derivative plot heavily borrowing from films like Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander, stock characters with little depth, and an overall lack of originality. A few critics found it passable as lightweight entertainment, but the majority dismissed it as a shallow and stilted exercise.
3 not-rated reviews aren't plotted
Positive = 6.5/10 and up · negative = below 5/10
AI-generated summary of 16 critic reviews · may contain errors
Report inaccuracyFrom the papers
Top critics first, then by score · not-rated last · updated
Top critic
Film review ·
Tiger Shroff, Ananya Panday and Tara Sutaria star as a new batch of students/professionally bred actors in sequel to Karan Johar's 2012 film.
Top critic
Film review ·
The running time is too long for what is, essentially, yet-another-buffed-up-version of Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander crossed with Kuch Kuch Hota Hai. This class of 2019 has predictable beats, which is to be expected in an underdog story, but that it is so stilted is disappointing.
Top critic
Film review ·
Tiger Shroff leads a fresh bunch of students in film so last decade in its thinking and packaging that sitting through it is like straying into a Bollywood time warp.
Film review ·
Overall, this chapter doesn't have much of that ishq wala love, but there is ample dosti, kabaddi and cool stuff to keep you going. Think of it as a much snazzier version of 'Jo Jeeta Wahi Sikander' minus the realism.
Film review ·
About the report card on the film, the SOTY second edition, although it does not pass with flying colours, does make the grade.
Film review ·
The problem with the film is that it seems confused – should it be a candyfloss campus flick with hot chicks and hunky dudes or should it be a candyfloss campus flick with sports and tense moments? It ends up being neither. What remains is the candyfloss. Which, in retrospect, isn't such a bad thing as you go for the movies to have a good time and be entertained. Student of the Year entertains but is too vanilla to have any lingering taste. In Hindi film parlance, I'd say, it's a decent timepass film worth the popcorn. But frankly, it's time for the students to graduate.
Film review ·
Helming the second in the franchise that catapulted the careers of Alia Bhatt, Sidharth Malhotra and Varun Dhawan, would surely come with great responsibility. But Malhotra plays it on the back-foot, hoping to crack it with a formulaic plot and clichéd characters that barely go beyond the call of duty. Perhaps, it's time for the makers to return to film school?
Film review ·
The dialogues sound like group chats where everyone tries to be the smartest. The songs and dances are unbearably campy. The retro number Yeh jawani hai deewani is the perfect anthem for a film dedicated to the "josh and junoon" of the young. Sadly not this one. Not this car wreck of a movie.
Film review ·
Tiger's acting or plot clichés — what's the worst part of this film?
Film review ·
Stupidity of the year!...'Student of the Year 2 has no spunk, no plot and zero charisma
Film review ·
The Karan Johar produced film is silly and formulaic with stock characters who are just pretty to ogle.
Film review ·
Apart from Will Smith's miss-if-you-blink appearance, watch SOTY (2) for Tiger. Even when things around him are caving in, his ballerina grace is intact.
Film review ·
Unless you are an ardent admirer of Tiger Shroff's flying kicks, stay away from Student Of The Year 2
Film review ·
SOTY2 can be described as a parody of Main Hoon Na, which itself was a parody of every desi college-campus movie ever made; a parody of a parody is called…reality
Film review ·
With his dancing skills and ripped body, Shroff is perfectly suited to the role of Rohan, but there is nothing in this film that we haven't seen him do before. A stony-faced Tara Sutaria comes off as too self-conscious in her attempt to play Mia. It is Ananya Pandey who stands out among what is otherwise a mediocre cast. As Shreya, she displays some spunk and life, and is the best thing about this film.
Film review ·
To be fair SOTY2 tries to be a little different, by adding a little Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikandar to K2H2. The poor "Pishorilal ka fukra" gets pitched against the "St Teresa dude" in the game of kabaddi, in much the same way as Model had a face off with Rajput in a cycle race in JJWS. But caught between two cult films, SOTY2 isn't able to acquire a personality of its own.
From our readers
1 rating · user score 3.0
Save for the 5-second performance of Will Smith that you may miss if you don't pay attention to the half a dozen opposite-of-glee songs in Student of the Year 2 and a few one-liner jokes by the breakout star Harsh Beniwal (whom I would like to see as the lead if they ever make Student of the Year 3), this one here will tickle your fantasies that are best left untickled. Do something better with you time if you don't want to go window cloth shopping. TN.
Credits
Tiger ShroffRohan Sehgal
Tara SutariaMridula
Aditya SealManav[11]
Sidharth MalhotraSpecial Appearance
Varun DhawanSpecial Appearance
Alia BhattHindi films like Student of the Year 2